Sign in
Get a Demo
Talk with an accountant.
Compare soft close and hard close accounting methods to find the best fit for your business. Learn key differences, pros, cons, and practical tips.
The month-end close often feels like a trade-off between speed and accuracy. You either rush through a soft close or brace for a long, manual hard close. But technology is changing this conversation. With the right automation, your approach to hard close accounting can be both fast and precise. A hard close doesn't have to be a resource-draining marathon, and a soft close can be more reliable than ever. This article examines both closing methods through a modern lens, showing you how to get the accuracy needed for a clean hard close audit and optimize your process.
Closing the books is a fundamental rhythm for any business, but how you approach it can make a huge difference. It’s not just about checking boxes; it’s about getting the financial data you need to make smart decisions. The terms "hard close" and "soft close" describe two distinct methods for finalizing your financial records for a period. One is a deep dive focused on absolute precision, while the other provides a quick, high-level overview. Understanding the difference is the first step toward building a closing process that truly supports your team and your company's goals. Let's break down what each approach means for your accounting operations.
A hard close is the most thorough method for closing your books. Think of it as a mini year-end close performed every month or quarter. During a hard close, your accounting team meticulously reviews and reconciles every account, verifying each transaction and ensuring all entries are accurate and fully documented. The goal is to produce highly precise financial statements that are audit-ready. This process is comprehensive, leaving no stone unturned and providing a high degree of confidence in your financial data. It’s a complete financial health check-up that confirms every number with verifiable proof, which is essential for external reporting to investors, lenders, or regulatory bodies.
You might hear the terms "hard close" and "fast close" used interchangeably, and for good reason. While a hard close describes the thoroughness of the process, a fast close emphasizes the speed at which it's completed. Think of it this way: the goal for most finance teams is to achieve a fast close—that is, to complete a comprehensive, audit-ready hard close in a much shorter timeframe. This isn't about cutting corners; it's about optimizing your workflow. By automating time-consuming tasks like data reconciliation and revenue recognition, you can significantly reduce the manual effort required. Having the right system integrations in place is key to pulling data efficiently and making a true fast close possible.
A soft close, on the other hand, is a faster, more streamlined approach. Instead of reconciling every single transaction down to the last penny, the focus is on major accounts and using reasonable estimates for less significant items. The primary goal here is speed. This method provides a quick snapshot of financial performance for internal management, allowing leaders to make timely decisions without getting bogged down in a lengthy reconciliation process. While the numbers are directionally correct and useful for internal reporting, they aren't as precise as those from a hard close and aren't intended to be audit-proof. It’s about getting good-enough data into the right hands, fast.
The core difference between a hard and soft close boils down to a trade-off: accuracy versus speed. A hard close prioritizes precision, giving you audit-ready financials at the cost of more time and resources. A soft close prioritizes speed, providing a quick overview for internal decision-making but with less detail and verification. Think of it this way: a hard close gives you a high-resolution, professionally edited photograph of your finances, while a soft close gives you a clear, instant snapshot from your phone. Neither is inherently better; the right choice depends on your company’s immediate needs, reporting requirements, and available resources. You can find more insights on financial operations on our blog.
So, how often should you be closing your books? The most common approach is a hybrid model that leverages the strengths of both methods. Many businesses perform a soft close every month to get a quick, reliable pulse on their financial health. This gives leadership the data they need to make informed operational decisions without waiting for a full-blown reconciliation. Then, once a year, they'll conduct a comprehensive hard close. This annual deep dive is crucial for tax preparation, annual audits, and providing the meticulously accurate financial reports required by investors, lenders, and the board. This schedule strikes a practical balance, offering timely insights throughout the year while ensuring you have audit-proof numbers when it matters most.
A hard close is the gold standard for financial accuracy, but it requires a structured and disciplined approach. Think of it as a deep clean of your books at the end of each period. It’s a thorough process that involves locking down the previous period to prevent any further changes, ensuring that your financial statements are precise, compliant, and ready for any audit. Let’s walk through what this process looks like in practice.
The hard close process is methodical, leaving no stone unturned. Your team will reconcile every single balance sheet account, from cash to accounts payable, ensuring the numbers match supporting documents. This also involves a detailed variance analysis to investigate any significant fluctuations from the previous period. All journal entries are finalized, and accruals are recorded to make sure revenue and expenses are recognized in the correct period. Meticulous documentation is key throughout, creating a clear audit trail that supports every number on your financial statements.
The main goal of a hard close is to produce financials you can trust completely. To achieve this, the books for the past period are kept open for a short time to capture any trailing transactions. This allows your team to confirm all revenue and expenses are recorded in the correct month, which is essential for adhering to accounting principles. This level of detail is critical for meeting compliance standards like ASC 606, ensuring your revenue recognition is spot-on. The result is a set of high-quality, reliable financial reports that accurately reflect your business's performance.
Because a hard close produces audit-ready financials, it often goes hand-in-hand with an audit process. A hard close audit is a strategic move that can significantly streamline your year-end reporting. Instead of cramming all the audit work into a few frantic weeks, this approach spreads it out, making the entire experience smoother for both your team and your auditors.
A hard close audit simply means performing a significant portion of your annual audit work before the fiscal year actually ends. The main goal is to get a head start by having auditors review key financial estimates and high-risk areas early on. This proactive approach allows you to identify and resolve potential issues well before the year-end rush. By tackling complex accounts when the details are still fresh, you reduce the pressure on your team and give everyone more time to address any findings, leading to a more efficient and less stressful final audit.
This strategy is most effective for companies that already have strong financial controls and can produce high-quality financial statements quickly. If your interim reports are unreliable or incomplete, an early audit won't save you any time—it might even create more work. Businesses that use automation to ensure data accuracy are prime candidates. For instance, having an automated revenue recognition system in place means you can generate precise, compliant reports on demand. This level of financial maturity is exactly what auditors look for and is the foundation of a successful hard close audit.
During a hard close audit, auditors will concentrate on areas that involve significant judgment or complexity. For the income statement, they'll look closely at revenue, cost of goods sold, and staffing costs. On the balance sheet, their attention will turn to items like goodwill, major equipment, money owed by customers (trade receivables), and bank loans. They focus on these accounts because they are often subject to estimates and have a material impact on the financial statements. Having clean, consolidated data from all your systems is crucial here, as it provides the clear audit trail they need. You can learn more about how HubiFi integrates with different platforms to create a single source of truth.
It’s a common misconception that an early audit adds to the total cost. In reality, a hard close audit shouldn't cost more than a traditional one. The process doesn't create more work; it simply shifts the timing of when that work gets done. By completing a large chunk of the audit earlier in the year, you reduce the workload required after the year-end. This can actually lead to cost savings by avoiding the premium fees associated with last-minute rushes and minimizing the internal resources needed to manage a condensed audit timeline.
Opting for a hard close comes with a clear set of trade-offs. The biggest advantage is the high degree of accuracy. You get reliable, GAAP-compliant financial reports every month, which empowers leadership to make smarter, data-driven decisions. These audit-ready financials also give investors and stakeholders greater confidence. On the flip side, the process is demanding. It requires significant time and effort from your accounting team, which can be a strain on resources, especially for smaller businesses. The intensity can sometimes lead to delays in closing the books if the team is stretched too thin.
To make the hard close manageable, it’s all about having a solid plan. Start by creating a detailed closing checklist with clear deadlines and assigned responsibilities for each task. This keeps everyone on the same page and holds the team accountable. Standardizing your procedures also helps reduce errors and saves time. Most importantly, leverage technology to automate repetitive tasks. Using tools that offer seamless integrations with your existing accounting software can dramatically speed up reconciliations and data entry, freeing up your team to focus on analysis rather than manual work.
Think of the soft close as the more flexible, agile cousin of the hard close. It’s a strategic approach that prioritizes speed and timely insights over absolute precision. Instead of locking down every single transaction, a soft close focuses on simplifying activities and addressing only the most significant, or "material," issues. This method gives you a clear, directional view of your financial performance without the time-consuming reconciliation of a full hard close. For businesses that need to make quick decisions based on current data, the soft close provides a valuable snapshot of the company’s financial health, allowing for adjustments and planning on the fly. It’s a practical way to keep your finger on the pulse of the business month after month.
The soft close process is a streamlined version of your month-end accounting. Your team will post major transactions, make key accruals, and reconcile major accounts, but they won't sweat the small stuff. The goal is to get a reasonably accurate picture quickly. Because the books aren't fully locked, they can be reopened later to make adjustments if needed. This flexibility is a core feature. The financial reports generated from a soft close are perfect for internal management meetings and trend analysis. They give you the essential data you need to guide operations, but they aren't intended for official audits or external stakeholders who require fully reconciled, GAAP-compliant statements.
We’ve all been there: the month is over, but invoices are still trickling in. During a hard close, you’d have to wait for every single bill to arrive before you could finalize the books. A soft close takes a more practical route. Instead of waiting, your team will use reasonable estimates for any missing expenses. For predictable costs like rent or software subscriptions, they can create an accrual based on previous months. This approach keeps the process moving, providing a timely financial snapshot for internal leaders. The goal isn't perfection; it's about getting a directionally accurate picture of performance so you can make decisions without delay. Any minor differences can be adjusted in the following month or during a more thorough quarterly close.
A soft close is all about strategic simplification. It intentionally skips the time-consuming tasks that have a low impact on the overall financial picture. For example, your team might not reconcile every single petty cash transaction or track down a tiny discrepancy in a prepaid expense account. Instead, they focus their energy on the big-ticket items: reconciling major bank accounts, posting significant revenue entries, and accruing for material expenses. This streamlined financial close process ensures that the most critical data is accurate while saving hours of work on less significant details. It’s a calculated trade-off that prioritizes speed and efficiency for internal reporting purposes.
The biggest advantage of a soft close is speed. It saves a tremendous amount of time and resources, freeing up your finance team to focus on more strategic analysis rather than tedious reconciliation. This allows you to get financial reports into the hands of decision-makers much faster. The main drawback, however, is the trade-off in accuracy. Because some entries might be estimated or deferred, there's a risk that income or expenses could be recorded in the wrong period. This can create a larger workload when it's time for the year-end hard close. Having seamless data integrations can help minimize these discrepancies by ensuring your information is as current as possible.
While a soft close offers flexibility, a few common missteps can cause problems down the road. The most frequent mistake is becoming too reliant on soft closes and putting off a hard close for too long, which allows small errors to compound. Another pitfall is poor documentation; just because the process is faster doesn't mean you can skip recording your assumptions and adjustments. Finally, avoid using soft close reports for official purposes like tax filings or investor updates, as they lack the necessary precision. Automating your revenue recognition can help you avoid these issues by maintaining accuracy and compliance even during a soft close. You can schedule a demo to see how this works.
Choosing between a hard and soft close isn't just an accounting decision—it sends ripples through your entire business. The method you pick directly influences your team's workload, the speed of your reporting, and the confidence you have in your financial data. It’s a classic balancing act between speed and precision, and finding the right rhythm for your company is key to making informed decisions without burning out your team.
Think of it this way: your close process sets the pace for your financial operations. A faster, more frequent close can give you a near real-time pulse on the business, while a more meticulous, slower process provides a rock-solid foundation for high-stakes reporting. Let's break down how this choice affects your day-to-day operations, from managing resources to leveraging technology.
The biggest trade-off between a hard and soft close comes down to accuracy versus resources. A hard close is the gold standard for precision. It involves a deep dive into every account, ensuring all entries are reconciled and your financial statements are highly accurate. While this level of detail is fantastic for audits and investor reports, it demands a significant investment of time and effort from your finance team.
On the other hand, a soft close is designed for speed. Your team performs fewer checks and reconciliations, which saves a ton of time and frees them up for other tasks. This approach is great for getting a quick snapshot of your financial health for internal use. The catch? You're sacrificing a degree of accuracy, which can accumulate over time and make your year-end hard close a much heavier lift.
Your closing method has a direct impact on how quickly you can get financial reports into the hands of decision-makers. A soft close allows you to close the books rapidly, which is a huge advantage for businesses that need to be agile and respond to market changes quickly. You can generate monthly reports in a matter of days, giving leadership a timely look at performance.
A hard close, by its nature, extends your closing timeline. The comprehensive checks and detailed analysis take time, which can delay reporting. While the final numbers are more reliable, the delay might mean the information is less actionable by the time it’s ready. It’s also important to remember that relying solely on soft closes all year can create a bottleneck during the annual audit, as your team scrambles to reconcile 12 months of less-detailed records.
This is where the right tools can completely change the game. Modern accounting technology helps bridge the gap between the speed of a soft close and the accuracy of a hard close. By automating repetitive tasks like data entry and reconciliations, you can streamline your monthly close process, regardless of which method you use. This not only saves time but also reduces the risk of human error.
Cloud-based solutions and seamless data integrations are particularly powerful. When your payment processor, CRM, and accounting software all speak the same language, you get real-time data synchronization. This eliminates the lag between business activity and financial reporting, giving you a clearer, more current view of your finances. The right tech stack can make a hard close less painful and a soft close more reliable.
Your close process is a team sport, and your chosen method affects how everyone plays together. A chaotic, poorly defined process—whether hard or soft—is a recipe for stress and mistakes. This is why clear documentation and cross-training are so important. When you document your closing process, you create a single source of truth that keeps everyone on the same page.
Effective communication is the glue that holds it all together. When your team members understand their roles, deadlines, and dependencies, the entire process runs more smoothly. This prevents misunderstandings that can cause delays and ensures that everyone is working toward the same goal: a timely, accurate close. A well-coordinated team can execute either a hard or soft close efficiently, reducing friction and improving morale.
Deciding between a hard and soft close isn't about picking the "best" one—it's about choosing the right one for your business right now. The ideal approach depends entirely on your company's unique situation. Think of it as a strategic decision, not just an accounting task. To make the right call, you need to look inward at your operations, resources, and goals. By evaluating a few key areas, you can land on a closing strategy that provides the accuracy you need without overwhelming your team or your budget.
The right closing strategy often comes down to your specific industry and business model. A small, local retail shop has very different financial reporting demands than a publicly-traded tech company. For example, if you're in a highly regulated field like finance or insurance, the rigorous, auditable trail of a hard close is likely a requirement for compliance. Similarly, high-volume businesses often need the strict controls of a hard close to manage complexity. The key is to tailor your closing strategy to fit the unique context of your operations, ensuring it meets both internal needs and external expectations.
Be realistic about what your team and budget can handle. A hard close is thorough, but it’s also resource-intensive. If you have a small accounting team already stretched thin, forcing a hard close every month could lead to burnout and errors. This is where technology plays a huge role. Automated solutions can significantly lighten the load, making a hard close more achievable even for smaller teams. Consider whether investing in tools that automate revenue recognition and data reconciliation could free up your team to focus on analysis instead of manual data entry. The right tools can make a complex process much more manageable.
Who are your financial statements for, and what do they need to see? This is a critical question. If you report to a board of directors, investors, or lenders, they’ll expect the high degree of accuracy and finality that comes with a hard close. These stakeholders rely on precise, locked-down numbers to make major decisions. On the other hand, if your primary audience is internal managers who need quick, directional insights to adjust strategy, the speed of a soft close might be more valuable. Your reporting requirements should be the foundation for your closing process and the financial statements you prepare.
Your team's experience level is a major factor in this decision. A hard close demands a deep understanding of accounting principles and a meticulous, process-driven approach. Does your team have the expertise to handle complex accruals, reconciliations, and journal entries without significant oversight? If not, implementing a hard close might introduce more errors than it prevents. It’s essential to document your closing process and provide training to get everyone on the same page. A soft close can be a practical interim step while you build your team’s skills and confidence for a more rigorous process down the line.
Your technology can either be a powerful enabler or a major roadblock. Trying to perform a hard close using disconnected spreadsheets is a recipe for frustration and costly mistakes. Modern, cloud-based accounting systems are designed to streamline and automate many steps of the month-end close. Take a look at your current tools. Do they talk to each other? Can you pull data automatically, or is everything a manual export and import? Having seamless integrations between your ERP, CRM, and payment processors is fundamental to an efficient close. The right tech stack doesn’t just speed things up—it improves accuracy and gives you better visibility into your financials.
Whether you choose a hard close, a soft close, or a hybrid approach, refining your process is always a smart move. A streamlined financial close saves time, reduces stress on your team, and delivers more reliable data for decision-making. The goal is to create a system that is repeatable, accurate, and efficient. By focusing on a few key areas, you can build a closing process that supports your business as it grows. It’s not about finding a perfect, one-time fix, but about committing to small, consistent improvements that add up over time. Here are five practical steps you can take to strengthen your financial close.
Manual data entry and reconciliations are not only time-consuming but also prime opportunities for human error. Take a close look at your current workflow and identify the most repetitive, rule-based tasks—these are perfect candidates for automation. Automated solutions can significantly simplify your financial close by handling tasks like revenue recognition, data consolidation, and report generation. This frees up your finance team to focus on more strategic work, like analysis and planning. The right tools should offer seamless integrations with your existing accounting software and ERPs, pulling data from different sources into one unified system without the manual copy-and-paste.
A solid closing process needs built-in checks and balances to ensure accuracy. Start by creating a detailed closing checklist that outlines every task, who is responsible, and when it’s due. This simple tool keeps everyone on the same page and makes the process predictable. Encourage peer reviews, where a second team member double-checks journal entries and reconciliations before they are finalized. Cross-training your accounting staff is another powerful quality control measure. When multiple people understand the entire process, they’re more likely to catch potential issues and can step in to help when a team member is unavailable, preventing bottlenecks.
You can't improve what you don't measure. To get a clear picture of your closing process, you need to track key performance indicators (KPIs). Start by monitoring the time it takes to close the books each month. Are you getting faster? Are there specific stages that consistently cause delays? Use your trial balance reports as the foundation for the close, as they provide a comprehensive look at all account activities. With real-time analytics, you can move beyond just looking at historical data and start monitoring financial health as it happens. This allows you to spot and address variances early, making the final close much smoother.
Clear documentation is the backbone of an efficient and scalable closing process. Create a central guide that details every step, from initial data collection to final report submission. This document should be clear enough for a new hire to follow with minimal assistance. Be sure to include procedures for handling non-routine transactions and define the specific criteria for closing accounts. This ensures that all incoming cash and expenses are recorded consistently and that nothing is overlooked. A well-documented process not only promotes consistency but also simplifies audits and makes it easier to train your team.
Your closing process shouldn't be set in stone. As your business evolves, your financial operations need to adapt. Schedule regular reviews—quarterly or semi-annually—to discuss what’s working and what isn’t. Gather feedback from your team to identify pain points and brainstorm solutions. Adopting modern, cloud-based solutions can be a game-changer, offering greater flexibility and more powerful automation features. If you’re ready to see how a more advanced system could transform your financial close, you can always schedule a demo to explore the possibilities. The key is to foster a mindset of ongoing refinement.
Whether you choose a hard close, a soft close, or a hybrid approach, your success depends on the system you build to support it. A strong closing system isn't just a checklist; it's a well-oiled machine powered by clear communication, the right technology, and a well-prepared team. It’s what turns a chaotic, stressful period into a predictable and efficient process. Building this framework requires a thoughtful approach to how your people, tools, and processes work together. By focusing on these core components, you can create a reliable system that delivers accurate financials on time, every time. The goal is to establish a repeatable process that not only meets your reporting deadlines but also provides valuable insights for strategic decision-making.
A smooth close starts with a team that’s perfectly in sync. When everyone understands their role and how their work impacts the overall process, you eliminate confusion and prevent costly delays. Effective communication is the foundation of this coordination. Start by clearly defining responsibilities for each team member involved in the close. Hold a kickoff meeting to review the schedule, outline key deadlines, and address any questions. Regular check-ins throughout the closing period can also help you identify and resolve potential bottlenecks before they become major problems. When your team operates from the same playbook, the entire process becomes more seamless and less stressful for everyone.
The right technology can transform your closing process from a manual marathon into an automated sprint. Modern financial tools are designed to handle repetitive tasks, reduce human error, and provide real-time visibility into your financial data. Automated solutions can significantly simplify your financial close, giving your team more time to focus on analysis rather than data entry. When evaluating software, look for platforms that offer seamless integrations with your existing systems, like your ERP and CRM. This ensures data flows smoothly across your entire tech stack, providing a single source of truth and enhancing the accuracy of your financial reports.
Investing in powerful software is only half the battle; your team needs to know how to use it effectively. Proper training ensures you get the full value from your technology and empowers your staff to perform their jobs with confidence. Go beyond basic onboarding and offer ongoing educational opportunities. Consider hosting hands-on workshops that cover advanced features, such as creating custom reports or setting up automated workflows. As you add new members to your team or update your software, make sure your training materials are current. A well-trained team is more efficient, makes fewer mistakes, and is better equipped to handle the complexities of the financial close.
A detailed and realistic timeline is your roadmap for a successful close. It should clearly outline every task, assign ownership, and set firm deadlines. Start by documenting your entire closing process from start to finish. This exercise helps you understand all the moving parts and identify opportunities for improvement. Once you have a documented process, you can build a timeline that allocates enough time for each step, including reviews and approvals. It’s also a good practice to cross-train your staff on critical tasks. This creates redundancy, ensuring that an unexpected absence won’t derail your entire schedule. If you need help structuring your process, you can always schedule a demo to see how an automated system can help.
Can my business use both a hard and a soft close? Absolutely. In fact, many businesses find a hybrid approach works best. You might perform a soft close for the first two months of a quarter to get quick, directional data for your management team. Then, at the end of the quarter, you can perform a full hard close to get a precise, audit-ready financial picture. This strategy gives you a great balance of speed for day-to-day decisions and accuracy for more formal reporting.
How often should we perform a hard close? The ideal frequency really depends on your reporting needs. For companies that report to investors or have strict lending covenants, a monthly hard close is often the standard. However, for many other businesses, a quarterly hard close is a perfectly effective and more manageable rhythm. The most important thing is to be consistent so you can reliably track performance and make meaningful comparisons over time.
What's the biggest risk of relying only on soft closes? The main danger is the compounding effect of small inaccuracies. While a soft close is great for a quick overview, minor discrepancies and un-reconciled items can pile up month after month. When it’s time for your annual audit or tax filing, your team will have to untangle a year's worth of these issues, which can be a massive and stressful undertaking. A periodic hard close helps you clean things up regularly.
My team is small. How can we possibly manage a monthly hard close? This is a very common concern, and the answer lies in using the right tools. A hard close doesn't have to be a completely manual effort. By automating repetitive tasks like data consolidation and account reconciliations, you can dramatically reduce the time and effort required. The right technology handles the heavy lifting, freeing up your team to focus on review and analysis, making a rigorous close achievable even for a small team.
So, is one method actually better than the other? Neither method is inherently better—it’s all about choosing the right tool for the job. A hard close is best when you need absolute precision for external stakeholders like investors, lenders, or auditors. A soft close is the better choice when your internal team needs financial data quickly to make timely operational decisions. The most effective strategy is the one that aligns with your company's specific resources, reporting requirements, and goals.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Meet with an expert in revenue recognition and order-to-cash accounting and automate revenue close.
*Or watch 2 minute demo here.
Power your high-volume business's revenue compliance and reporting needs with one platform.
