Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Get a Demo
See your data in HubiFi < 2 days
Understand gift card breakage accounting with this complete guide, covering key concepts, compliance, and best practices for accurate financial reporting.
Gift cards are a fantastic way to secure upfront cash flow and bring in new customers, but they also create a tricky liability on your balance sheet. When you sell a $50 gift card, you haven't earned that money yet—you've made a promise to provide goods or services later. This deferred revenue can sit on your books for years, potentially misrepresenting your financial position. The solution lies in mastering gift card breakage accounting. This is the formal process for recognizing the portion of gift card funds you reasonably expect will never be used, turning that long-term liability into reportable revenue and giving you a clearer, more accurate picture of your company's performance.
Have you ever found a gift card in your wallet with a few dollars left on it, long after you’ve forgotten it was there? That leftover, unspent money is what the accounting world calls “breakage.” Simply put, gift card breakage is the portion of a gift card's value that a customer never redeems. For your business, this represents the money from gift cards sold that will likely never be claimed for goods or services. While it might sound like free money, it’s a bit more complicated than that.
When you sell a gift card, you haven't actually earned that money yet. Instead, you've created a promise to your customer—an obligation to provide a product or service in the future. This obligation sits on your books as a liability. Recognizing breakage revenue is the process of figuring out when that promise is unlikely to be fulfilled and you can finally count the cash as earned income. Getting this right is essential for accurate financial reporting and staying compliant with accounting standards like ASC 606. It requires a reliable system for estimating when redemption is remote, which is often based on your company’s historical data and customer behavior patterns.
Understanding breakage is crucial because it directly impacts how you report your revenue and liabilities. When a customer buys a $100 gift card, your cash goes up, but so does your deferred revenue liability. You haven't made a sale in the traditional sense; you've accepted payment for a future sale. This is a critical distinction for maintaining an accurate balance sheet. Your business has an obligation to provide goods or services until that card is used. Recognizing breakage allows you to systematically reduce that liability over time and reflect a more accurate picture of your company's financial health. Without a proper method for this, your liabilities could appear inflated for years.
The process of accounting for breakage directly moves money from your liability column to your revenue column. When you can reasonably estimate that a portion of a gift card’s value will go unused, you can recognize that amount as breakage revenue. This is based on the principle of unexercised customer rights, where you anticipate keeping some of the prepaid amount. In accounting terms, you would make a journal entry to decrease your deferred revenue liability and increase your breakage revenue. This adjustment flows directly to your income statement, increasing your reported profits for the period and giving you a clearer view of your true performance.
If you’ve ever felt a little fuzzy on the rules for gift card accounting, you’re not alone. The key is to understand ASC 606, the accounting standard that sets the rules for recognizing revenue from customer contracts. While it might sound complicated, the core idea is simple: you can’t count your money until you’ve delivered the goods or services you promised. For gift cards, this means the sale isn't complete when a customer buys the card—it's complete when they redeem it. This is a major shift from just booking the cash as revenue right away. Instead, selling a gift card creates a liability on your books because you owe the customer something in the future.
Getting this right is essential for accurate financial reporting and staying compliant, especially as your business grows. The good news is that ASC 606 also provides a clear framework for handling the portion of gift cards that go unused, which we know as breakage. By following these principles, you can ensure your financials are accurate and pass any audit with flying colors. Automating this process with the right tools can save you from manual headaches and give you a real-time view of your financial health. You can find more helpful articles like this one by exploring the HubiFi blog. For high-volume businesses, managing these liabilities manually is nearly impossible, which is why having a system that handles integrations with your existing software is so important.
At its heart, ASC 606 is about timing. It requires you to recognize revenue only when you transfer control of your promised goods or services to the customer. When someone buys a $50 gift card, they haven't received any goods yet; they've simply paid you in advance. That $50 is considered deferred revenue—a liability you owe. The revenue is only earned when the customer comes back and uses the card to make a purchase.
This is also where breakage comes into play. ASC 606 allows companies to recognize breakage revenue for the portion of gift card value they expect will never be redeemed. You can’t just guess, though. You need to estimate this amount based on your company’s historical data and recognize it in proportion to when customers redeem their cards. This prevents you from leaving that liability on your books forever while still following a structured accounting process.
Let's walk through how this looks in practice. When a customer buys a gift card, you record the cash you received, but instead of crediting a revenue account, you credit a liability account, often called "Deferred Gift Card Revenue" or "Unearned Revenue." This entry shows that while you have the cash, you still have an obligation to fulfill. Your income statement remains unchanged at this point.
Once the customer redeems the card, you can finally recognize the revenue. If they use the full amount, you simply decrease the deferred revenue liability and increase your sales revenue by the same amount. If they only use a portion, you recognize revenue for the redeemed amount and keep the remaining balance as a liability. This is where having a reliable system for gift card accounting becomes critical for tracking those outstanding balances accurately.
Under ASC 606, you can’t just wait for a gift card to expire to recognize breakage. You need to proactively estimate the amount you expect will go unredeemed. Getting this number right is key to keeping your financial statements accurate and compliant. It’s not about guesswork; it’s about using the data you already have. Think of it as an educated forecast based on past trends, industry standards, and customer behavior. This isn’t a one-time calculation. You’ll want to revisit your estimate regularly to make sure it still reflects your current business reality.
The best place to start is with your own sales history. Dig into your records to see how many gift cards were sold versus how many were redeemed over the past few years. This helps you calculate your historical forfeiture rate—the percentage of gift card value left on the table. For example, if you sold $100,000 in gift cards and $90,000 was redeemed, you have a solid, data-backed starting point for your estimate. Having a system that provides clear insights into your financial data makes this process much simpler.
What if your business is new or you don’t have enough historical data? You can turn to industry benchmarks. Look for data on typical breakage rates for businesses similar to yours in size and sector. While not as precise as using your own numbers, this is an acceptable method under accounting standards when company-specific data isn't available. Remember that this should be a temporary solution. Your goal is to gather enough of your own gift card sales data to develop a more accurate, customized rate as soon as you can.
Your breakage rate isn’t static—it can change as your business evolves and customer habits shift. That’s why it’s important to continuously study customer behavior. Are redemption patterns different after a big sale or during the holidays? Answering these questions helps you refine your estimate over time. According to guidance from PwC, companies must estimate expected breakage rather than waiting for rights to expire. This means periodic reviews are essential for staying compliant and accurate.
Knowing when to count breakage as revenue is one of the trickiest parts of gift card accounting. It’s not as simple as waiting for a card to expire. Under ASC 606, the timing is tied to customer behavior. You need to recognize breakage revenue in proportion to how customers are actually redeeming their gift cards. This means you can’t just let that deferred revenue sit on your balance sheet indefinitely.
Getting the timing right is essential for accurate financial statements and staying compliant. The key is to move from a passive "wait-and-see" approach to a proactive, data-driven one. When you have a clear view of redemption patterns, you can confidently recognize revenue as it’s earned, giving you a truer picture of your company's performance. This is where having a system that can process and analyze sales data in real time becomes incredibly valuable for making sound financial decisions.
Under ASC 606, breakage is the revenue you recognize from unexercised customer rights—in this case, the unused balance on a gift card. The rules state that you should recognize this revenue as customers redeem their cards. Think of it this way: as gift cards are used, you earn a proportional amount of the total breakage you expect. For example, if customers have redeemed 60% of the value of gift cards sold in a specific period, you can recognize 60% of the estimated breakage for that same batch of cards. This method ensures your revenue recognition aligns with the actual pattern of redemption, rather than waiting years for a card to expire.
You can't recognize breakage revenue without first estimating how much you expect to occur. ASC 606 requires you to assess the likelihood of redemption and make a reasonable prediction. This isn't a wild guess; it's an informed estimate based on your company's historical data and customer behavior patterns. You must be able to support your breakage rate with solid evidence. This is why having access to clean, organized data is so important. By analyzing past sales, redemption speeds, and card expiration data, you can build a reliable model for predicting future breakage. The more data you can integrate and analyze, the more accurate your forecast will be, keeping your financial reporting both compliant and precise.
Once you've estimated your breakage rate, you can apply it to your gift card sales. For example, if you sell $100,000 in gift cards and your historical data suggests a 10% breakage rate, you can expect to recognize $10,000 in breakage revenue from that sales cohort. The accounting entry typically involves moving funds from your deferred revenue liability account to a breakage revenue account. This isn't a one-and-done task; it's an ongoing process. You'll apply this rate as gift cards are redeemed over time. Automating this process is the best way to ensure accuracy and efficiency, especially for high-volume businesses. A robust system can handle these calculations automatically, helping you close your books faster and with more confidence. If you're curious how automation can streamline this, you can always schedule a demo to see it in action.
Beyond getting your accounting right, you also have to think about legal compliance. When a gift card goes unused, the money doesn't always stay with your business indefinitely. Different states have specific rules about what happens to that unclaimed cash, and following them is essential to keep your business in good standing. This is where things can get a little tricky, especially if you sell to customers across the country. But with the right information and tracking, you can handle it without a headache.
Escheatment is a legal term for the process of turning over unclaimed property to the state. Think of it as a lost and found for money. After a certain period of inactivity, many states require businesses to report and hand over the value of unused gift cards. These unclaimed property laws exist to protect consumers, ensuring their money doesn't just disappear into a company's revenue. For your business, this means you can't simply keep all the breakage revenue forever. Understanding your state's specific dormancy period—the time before a card is considered abandoned—is the first step toward compliance and avoiding potential fines.
Here’s the catch: escheatment laws are not the same everywhere. Each state sets its own rules, and they can vary quite a bit. Some states have very clear regulations about when and how to report unused gift card balances, while others might exempt gift cards entirely. If you operate in multiple states, you need to be aware of the specific gift card breakage accounting rules for each one. This complexity is why you can't apply a one-size-fits-all approach. Staying informed about the regulations in every state where you do business is key to remaining compliant and ensuring that unclaimed funds are handled correctly.
To comply with varying escheatment laws, you need a system that meticulously tracks gift card sales and redemptions by location. Without this data, it's nearly impossible to know which state's rules to apply to an unredeemed card. Your point-of-sale or gift card management system should provide detailed reports that break down this information clearly. Having robust integrations with HubiFi can connect your sales data directly to your accounting system, making this tracking process seamless. This detailed record-keeping isn't just good practice; it's your best defense against compliance issues and ensures you can accurately report any unclaimed balances as required by law.
Gift card accounting seems simple on the surface, but a few common challenges can trip up even the most careful finance teams. While gift cards are a fantastic tool for driving upfront cash flow and attracting new customers, they create a deferred revenue liability that needs to be managed with precision. The real complexity emerges when you account for breakage—the portion of gift card value that customers never redeem. Getting this wrong can distort your revenue and profit margins, leading to inaccurate financial statements that mislead stakeholders and complicate strategic planning.
Beyond breakage, you have to consider the nuances of promotional offers. A simple discount is accounted for differently than a "buy one, get one" style deal, and misinterpreting these can throw your books out of balance. Then there’s the challenge of managing multiple gift card programs, each with its own unique customer behavior and redemption rate. Juggling data from physical cards, e-gift cards, and third-party sellers without a unified system is a recipe for errors. These hurdles aren’t just about bookkeeping; they’re about compliance. Staying on top of ASC 606 guidelines and varying state escheatment laws is non-negotiable. Tackling these issues head-on with a clear strategy ensures your financial close process is smooth and your business is audit-ready at all times.
The foundation of breakage accounting is a solid, defensible estimate. A wild guess won’t cut it during an audit, so you need a method grounded in data. Your best bet is to use your own historical information, analyzing redemption patterns over the last five to ten years to build a reliable model. If your business is new and lacks that history, you can start with an industry benchmark—many restaurants, for example, begin by assuming 5-10% of gift card value will go unredeemed. The key is to not "set it and forget it." You should regularly review and adjust your breakage estimates to reflect any changes in customer behavior or your own business practices. This ongoing analysis is crucial for maintaining accuracy.
Promotions are a great way to sell more gift cards, but they add a layer of complexity to your accounting. It’s important to distinguish between a simple discount and a promotional value add. For instance, if you sell a $25 gift card for a discounted price of $20, you only have a $20 liability on your books, and any breakage is calculated based on that amount. However, if you run a "buy a $100 gift card, get a $20 card for free" deal, that extra $20 is treated differently. This promotional value is considered a deferred expense, which you’ll recognize as the customer uses the gift card. Getting this distinction right is essential for proper revenue recognition and ASC 606 compliance.
Many businesses run more than one type of gift card program simultaneously, and treating them all the same is a common mistake. You might sell physical cards in-store, digital cards online, and bulk cards to corporate partners, and each of these can have very different redemption patterns. Because of this, the best practice is to calculate breakage separately for each program. This requires a robust system for tracking sales, redemptions, and even the state where each card was sold to handle escheatment laws. Without a centralized view, you risk inaccurate calculations and compliance headaches. Centralizing this data with powerful integrations is the only way to manage this complexity effectively and maintain clean, auditable records.
Getting gift card accounting right doesn't have to be a constant headache. While the rules can feel dense, building a few key habits into your financial routine makes all the difference. By implementing a solid tracking system, regularly reviewing your numbers, and performing internal check-ups, you can handle gift card revenue with confidence. These practices keep your financial statements accurate and protect your business from compliance issues down the road. Let’s walk through the essential steps to get your gift card accounting in top shape.
The foundation of accurate gift card accounting is a reliable tracking system. You need a clear view of every card sold, the amount redeemed, and the outstanding balance at any given moment. A good system makes year-end closing much smoother and helps you stay on top of compliance without last-minute scrambling. When choosing a provider, look for one that offers detailed reporting on sales, redemptions, and purchase locations. This data is crucial for calculating breakage accurately. The right tools often depend on seamless integrations between your point-of-sale (POS) and accounting software.
Your breakage rate isn't a number you can calculate once and forget about. Customer habits change, and your estimates need to reflect that. It's a best practice to review and adjust your breakage estimate at each financial reporting period. This is especially important for gift card programs that last a long time or never expire, as redemption likelihood can shift over the years. These periodic reviews ensure your revenue recognition remains accurate and compliant with ASC 606 principles for unexercised rights. Staying proactive keeps your financial statements reliable.
Regularly auditing your gift card processes internally is a smart way to catch potential issues before they become significant problems. This involves verifying that you’re keeping detailed records of all sales, redemptions, and the state where each card was sold. This location data is vital for navigating state-specific escheatment laws. Failing to account for gift cards correctly can lead to inaccurate financial reports and potential fines. If your process has gaps, getting expert guidance can help you build a system that ensures accuracy and makes future audits a breeze.
Trying to manage gift card accounting with spreadsheets is like trying to build a house with a single screwdriver—it’s possible, but it’s going to be messy, slow, and probably not up to code. For any business dealing with a high volume of transactions, having the right technology is non-negotiable. The right tools don’t just track sales and redemptions; they provide the data you need to accurately estimate breakage, stay compliant with ASC 606, and make informed business decisions. Think of it as building a tech stack where each tool has a specific job, but they all work together seamlessly.
Your goal is to create a system that gives you a clear, real-time view of your gift card liability. This means your sales system, accounting software, and any dedicated gift card platforms need to communicate effectively. When these systems are siloed, you’re left manually piecing together data, which opens the door to errors and wastes valuable time. The key is to find solutions that offer robust reporting and, most importantly, can be connected. Having strong integrations between your platforms automates the flow of information, ensuring the data you use for financial reporting is always accurate and up-to-date.
Your POS system is the frontline of your gift card program. It’s where every sale and redemption is recorded, making it the foundational source of your data. A reliable POS is essential for tracking gift card balances accurately from the moment a card is activated. This initial data capture is crucial for following accounting rules and maintaining a clear picture of your outstanding liabilities. Without a solid POS system in place, you’re starting on shaky ground, which can create headaches and stress when it’s time to close the books at the end of the month or year. Make sure your system can handle gift card tracking with precision.
While your POS system tracks the transactions, your accounting software is where you make sense of it all for your financial statements. This is where you’ll apply the principles of ASC 606 to recognize revenue appropriately. It’s important to use software that provides detailed reports on gift card activity, including sales data, redemption locations, and outstanding balances. These reports make the accounting process much smoother and more accurate. You can find more insights on how to manage complex accounting topics on our blog. Ultimately, your accounting software translates raw transaction data into compliant financial reporting, giving you a clear view of your company’s performance.
For businesses with more complex gift card programs, a dedicated platform can be a game-changer. These platforms often offer more advanced features than a standard POS, such as detailed analytics on customer behavior and multi-location management. The most critical feature, however, is its ability to integrate with your other systems. A good tracking system should work in harmony with your POS and accounting software to create a single source of truth for your gift card data. If you’re struggling to connect these disparate systems and get a clear view of your financials, it might be time to schedule a demo to see how automation can solve these challenges for you.
Why can't I just book the cash as revenue when I sell a gift card? When you sell a gift card, you haven't actually earned that money yet because you still owe the customer a product or service. Think of it as a prepayment. The cash goes into your bank account, but it sits on your books as a liability—a promise you have to fulfill. You only recognize the revenue once the customer redeems the card and you've delivered on that promise. This approach keeps your financial statements accurate and compliant with accounting standards.
What if my business is new and I don't have historical data to estimate breakage? This is a common spot to be in. If you don't have several years of your own data to analyze, you can start by using industry benchmarks. Look for typical breakage rates for businesses in your sector and of a similar size. This is an acceptable starting point under ASC 606, but you should treat it as a temporary measure. The goal is to begin tracking your own sales and redemption data immediately so you can develop a more accurate, customized rate as soon as possible.
Do I really have to worry about escheatment laws for every single state? If you sell gift cards to customers in different states, then yes, you do. Escheatment, or unclaimed property law, is determined by the customer's location, not your business's headquarters. Since the rules vary significantly from one state to another, you need a system that tracks where each gift card was sold. This is a critical compliance step that helps you avoid potential penalties and ensures you handle unclaimed funds correctly.
My POS system already tracks gift cards. Isn't that enough? While your POS system is essential for tracking sales and redemptions, it's usually just the first step. It captures the raw transaction data but typically doesn't handle the complex accounting required by ASC 606, like applying your breakage estimate or managing the deferred revenue liability over time. For accurate financial reporting, that POS data needs to connect seamlessly with your accounting software. A standalone POS system often leaves you with manual work and a higher risk of errors.
How often should I be updating my breakage rate? Your breakage rate isn't something you can set once and forget about. Customer behavior changes over time, so you should review and adjust your estimate at each financial reporting period, or at least annually. Regular reviews ensure your financial statements are a true reflection of your business's performance and that your revenue recognition practices stay compliant. This proactive habit keeps your books clean and audit-ready.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Copyright © 2025 HubiFi | All rights reserved.
