Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Get a Demo
See your data in HubiFi < 2 days
Get clear, actionable steps for consignment revenue recognition. Learn how to track sales, manage inventory, and stay compliant with accounting standards.
If you’ve ever sold something for a friend and split the profit, you already understand the basics of a consignment arrangement. You hold their item, sell it, and then pay them their share. In the business world, the accounting for this is more formal. The core principle you need to master is consignment revenue recognition, which dictates that the original owner can only record a sale after the final customer makes a purchase. Until then, the product is still their inventory, even if it's sitting in your shop. We’ll break down how this works, what it means for your balance sheet, and how to manage it correctly.
Let's break down consignment revenue recognition. It’s an accounting principle that dictates you, the consignor, can only recognize revenue when your product is sold to the final customer. It’s all about timing. Even though your inventory is in a consignee's shop, the sale isn't official on your books until that end customer buys it. In a consignment arrangement, you retain ownership of the goods until this final sale occurs. This is a fundamental concept under modern accounting standards like ASC 606, which focuses on the transfer of control. Getting this right is essential for accurate financials and ensuring your revenue recognition practices are compliant.
A consignment arrangement involves two players: the consignor (product owner) and the consignee (third-party seller). You provide goods to the consignee, but they don’t pay for them until they are sold. This isn't a typical wholesale deal where a retailer buys inventory upfront. Instead, the consignee acts as a sales agent, selling products on your behalf. Once a sale is made, the consignee pays you the proceeds, minus their agreed-upon commission. This structure is what distinguishes consignment from other sales models.
In any consignment relationship, the consignor always retains ownership of the inventory until it's sold to the end customer. Even when your products are at the consignee's store, they are still legally yours. This is a critical point for accounting because the inventory remains on your balance sheet, not the consignee's. You bear the risks associated with that inventory, like potential damage or it not selling. Because you still own and control the goods, you can't recognize revenue just from transferring them to your selling partner.
One of the biggest misconceptions is that a sale occurs the moment goods are delivered to a consignee. That’s not the case. In a true consignment arrangement, you maintain control over the products. This means you can request the goods back or move them to another seller. The consignee doesn't have an unconditional right to the goods; they are just holding them to make a sale. This lack of control by the consignee is a key factor that determines when revenue can be recognized under current accounting guides.
A consignment arrangement is a partnership where one business (the consignor) provides goods to another business (the consignee) to sell on their behalf. Think of it as placing your products in someone else’s shop without selling it to them first. The consignor retains ownership of the goods until they are sold to the final customer. This distinction is critical because it directly impacts when and how you recognize revenue. Understanding the specific roles and the point at which control transfers is the key to keeping your books accurate and compliant.
This model can be a fantastic way to expand your market reach without the overhead of opening new locations, but it comes with its own set of accounting rules. Let's break down how it all fits together.
If you are the consignor, you are the owner of the goods. Your role is to provide your products to the consignee, but you don't record a sale at that point. The inventory remains on your books even though it's physically located at the consignee’s place of business. You are essentially trusting another party to sell your product for you. Your responsibility is to track that inventory and wait for the consignee to report a sale to an end customer. Only then have you fulfilled your obligation and can you recognize the revenue from that sale.
As the consignee, you are the seller or the storefront. You hold the consignor's goods and work to sell them to customers, but you never take ownership of the inventory. Because of this, you do not record the consigned goods as your own assets. Your revenue comes from the commission or fee you earn for successfully selling the product. You recognize this commission as revenue only when the sale to the third-party customer is complete. Your primary role is to act as a sales agent for the consignor, manage the point of sale, and provide accurate reporting back to them.
This is the million-dollar question in consignment accounting. Revenue should only be recognized when the consignor has transferred control of the goods to the final customer. Sending your inventory to a consignee does not count as a transfer of control. The guidance is clear: if the customer hasn't truly gained control, the consignor cannot record the revenue. Control means the customer can direct the use of the product and receive the benefits from it. Until that happens, the product is still the consignor's inventory, just sitting in a different location.
In accounting terms, a sale happens when a "performance obligation" is satisfied. For the consignor, the performance obligation is not fulfilled by simply delivering goods to the consignee. The obligation is only met when the consignee sells the product to an end customer. For the consignor to recognize revenue, three conditions must be met: the goods have been sold to a customer, the consignor has received clear and timely sales reports from the consignee, and the consignor is certain they will be paid by the consignee. This ensures revenue is recorded accurately and reflects the true economic substance of the transaction.
The timing of revenue recognition is probably the trickiest part of consignment accounting. Unlike a standard sale where you recognize revenue the moment a product ships, consignment has its own set of rules. The core principle is this: you, the consignor, only recognize revenue when the consignee sells your product to the final customer. Until that sale happens, the goods are still your inventory, just sitting in someone else’s store. Getting this timing right is fundamental to staying compliant and keeping your financial statements accurate.
In a consignment deal, you can only count the money from a sale after the goods are actually sold to a customer—not when you first hand them over to the consignee. It helps to think of it this way: sending your products to a retailer is just like moving your inventory from your warehouse to another location. A sale hasn't happened yet. This is a critical distinction because it directly impacts your financial reporting. Recognizing revenue too early inflates your sales figures and can create major compliance headaches, especially under standards like ASC 606.
Since you keep ownership of the goods until the final sale, you also carry the risk for any unsold items. If the products don't sell, get damaged, or go out of style while at the consignee's shop, that's on you. The consignor is responsible for the goods throughout the arrangement. This means any unsold items stay on your balance sheet as inventory. If they become obsolete, you’ll have to account for that by writing down the inventory value, which directly affects your bottom line. This is another key reason why you can't recognize the revenue upfront.
Customer returns add another layer of complexity to the mix. When a customer buys your product from the consignee and later returns it, this can delay or even reverse the revenue you’ve already recorded. You need a solid process for handling these adjustments. A common practice is to set up a reserve for sales returns based on historical data to avoid overstating revenue. This ensures your financial statements reflect the reality that some sales will be returned, giving you a more accurate picture of your net revenue and helping you manage your financial operations more effectively.
Because you don’t have a direct line of sight to the consignee's sales floor, you need a reliable way to verify sales data. It’s essential to keep careful track of all your goods held by different consignees. You should ask for sales reports frequently—whether daily, weekly, or monthly—as laid out in your consignment agreement. Using software to get this data automatically can save a ton of time and reduce errors. The right tools with seamless integrations can pull sales data directly from the consignee’s system into yours, giving you real-time visibility without the manual back-and-forth.
When you're dealing with consignment, your accounting isn't just about tracking what goes out and what cash comes in. You need to follow specific accounting standards to make sure your financial statements are accurate and compliant. The two main sets of rules you'll hear about are ASC 606 and IFRS 15. Both were created to standardize how companies report revenue, and they have a lot to say about consignment sales.
The biggest takeaway from these standards is that you can't recognize revenue just because you've shipped your products to a consignee. The key moment is when the end customer buys the product and takes control of it. This means you need a clear line of sight into your consignees' sales activity. Getting this right is crucial for presenting a true picture of your company's financial health, passing audits, and making informed business decisions. Let's break down what you need to know to stay on the right side of these rules.
If your business operates in the U.S., ASC 606 is the revenue recognition standard you'll follow. The core principle is simple: you recognize revenue when you satisfy a performance obligation by transferring control of a good or service to a customer. In a consignment setup, you don't record revenue when you send inventory to your retail partner. Instead, revenue is recognized only when the consignee sells your product to the final customer. This is because the consignee never truly takes control of the inventory; they're simply holding it for you. This principle ensures your revenue figures reflect actual sales, which is essential for accurate ASC 606 compliance.
For businesses outside the U.S. or those that need to report internationally, IFRS 15 is the standard to follow. The good news is that it’s very similar to ASC 606, especially when it comes to consignment. Just like its U.S. counterpart, IFRS 15 states that revenue should be recognized when the customer gains control of the goods. In a consignment arrangement, this transfer of control happens at the point of sale to the end consumer. So, whether you're following ASC 606 or IFRS 15, your process remains the same: track sales at the consignee level and recognize revenue only when a final sale is made.
Transparency is a huge part of both ASC 606 and IFRS 15. To meet disclosure requirements, you need a clear and detailed consignment agreement. This document is your foundation for proper accounting and a lifesaver if questions ever come up during an audit. A strong agreement should outline the parties involved, provide a detailed description of the goods, and specify payment terms and commission rates. It also needs to clarify who is responsible for unsold or damaged goods. Putting everything in writing creates a clear record of the arrangement and ensures everyone is on the same page, which is critical for compliance.
Great agreements are just the start; you also need solid documentation to back up your numbers. As a consignor, it's your responsibility to maintain precise records of all inventory held by your consignees. This means you need a system for tracking what you've sent them, what they've sold, and what they still have on hand. You’ll also need to get timely and accurate sales reports from your partners. This flow of information is essential because it provides the data you need to recognize revenue accurately and on time. Without it, you’re just guessing, which is a risky place to be.
Once you have a handle on the accounting principles, the next step is putting them into practice. Managing consignment inventory and revenue effectively comes down to having solid systems and clear communication. Without them, you risk inaccurate financial statements and strained relationships with your partners. Think of it as building the operational backbone for your consignment strategy. By setting up clear processes for tracking inventory, reporting sales, calculating commissions, and verifying data, you create a reliable framework that ensures your books are always accurate and audit-ready.
Even though your products are with a consignee, they are still your assets and must be tracked on your balance sheet. This is why a robust inventory control system is non-negotiable. You need a clear view of which products are with which consignees, what has been sold, and what remains. A simple spreadsheet might work when you’re starting out, but as you grow, you’ll need a system that can handle more complexity. The goal is to maintain a perpetual record of your inventory, no matter its physical location. This detailed tracking is fundamental to accurate financial reporting and prevents stockouts or overstock situations.
You can only recognize revenue after the consignee sells your product to the end customer. This makes timely and accurate sales reports from your consignees absolutely critical. Don't leave this to chance. Your consignment agreement should clearly outline the reporting process, including the frequency (e.g., weekly, monthly) and the specific data you need. Establishing a standardized reporting format ensures you get consistent information, which simplifies your accounting. Automating this data flow through system integrations can eliminate manual entry errors and give you a real-time look at sales performance, making revenue recognition much smoother.
Ambiguity around commissions is a common source of conflict in consignment relationships. To avoid any confusion, your agreement must explicitly detail the commission structure. Will the consignee earn a flat fee per item sold or a percentage of the sales price? Are there different commission tiers based on volume? What happens to the commission in the case of a customer return? Answering these questions upfront and documenting them in your contract protects both parties. This clarity ensures the consignee is compensated correctly and you can accurately record the commission expense against the recognized revenue, keeping your financial statements precise.
With inventory located off-site, strong internal controls are essential for safeguarding your assets and ensuring data integrity. It’s not enough to just receive reports from your consignee; you need to verify them. A key internal control is to regularly reconcile the consignee’s sales and inventory reports with your own records. This process helps you quickly spot discrepancies, investigate potential issues like damage or theft, and confirm that your revenue recognition is accurate. Implementing automated checks and balances can make these reconciliations more efficient and less prone to human error. Seeing how these controls work in an automated system can provide valuable insights into strengthening your financial operations.
Consignment arrangements can be a fantastic way to expand your market reach without the overhead of new storefronts. But they also introduce some unique operational and financial hurdles that can catch even seasoned business owners off guard. From tracking inventory you don't physically hold to figuring out exactly when you've made a sale, these challenges can quickly complicate your books and strain partner relationships. You might find yourself struggling with cash flow because revenue isn't recognized when you expect, or losing money on inventory that's sitting unsold hundreds of miles away. Add in the complexity of managing different commission structures, sales reports, and legal agreements for each partner, and it's easy to see how things can get messy. The good news is that none of these issues are insurmountable. With a clear strategy and the right systems, you can manage these complexities effectively. It all comes down to understanding the specific pressure points in the consignment model and putting processes in place to address them head-on. By anticipating these challenges, you can protect your business, maintain healthy relationships with your partners, and ensure your financial reporting is always accurate and compliant.
One of the biggest points of confusion in consignment is timing. You don't recognize revenue the moment you ship goods to a consignee. Instead, you can only count the sale once the consignee sells the product to the end customer. Why? Because that’s the moment the "transfer of control" officially happens. Until that final sale, the inventory is still yours. This principle is a cornerstone of modern revenue recognition standards. Getting this timing wrong can throw off your financial statements and lead to compliance issues, so it’s critical to base your revenue recognition on the final sale date, not the shipping date.
Since you retain ownership of the goods until they're sold, you also carry the financial risk. If products sit on a consignee's shelf for too long, they can become outdated or lose value, and that's a cost your business has to absorb. Keeping a close eye on inventory across all your consignment partners is essential. Without accurate, real-time data, it's easy to lose track of what's selling and what's not. This is where having a centralized view of your operations becomes invaluable, helping you make smarter decisions about stock levels and product lifecycle before slow-moving inventory starts eating into your profits.
A vague agreement is a recipe for disaster in a consignment relationship. Your consignment contract is your single source of truth and should be incredibly clear to protect both you and your partner. Make sure it explicitly outlines key details like the commission structure, how and when the consignee reports sales, and who is responsible if goods are lost, damaged, or stolen. A strong, detailed agreement minimizes misunderstandings and provides a clear framework for how the partnership will operate. It’s always a good idea to have a legal professional review your standard consignment contract to ensure it’s airtight.
Relying on manual reports from your consignees can be a major headache. You're dependent on their accuracy and timeliness, which leaves room for human error and delays. This gets even trickier when you're trying to adhere to accounting standards like ASC 606, where determining the exact moment of "control transfer" is crucial. When your sales data lives in one system and your accounting in another, reconciliation becomes a time-consuming chore. This is where seamless integrations between your platforms can make a world of difference, automating data flow and giving you a reliable, real-time picture of your consignment sales without the manual work.
Getting consignment accounting right doesn't have to be a constant headache. With a solid framework in place, you can maintain clear visibility over your inventory and recognize revenue with confidence. It all comes down to establishing clear rules, consistent processes, and using the right tools to connect the dots. Think of it as building a strong foundation—the clearer your processes are from the start, the fewer issues you'll face down the line.
Putting these best practices into action will help you avoid common pitfalls like inaccurate sales data from consignees and confusion over inventory levels. Instead of chasing down reports and manually reconciling numbers, you can focus on what the data is telling you about your business. Let’s walk through four key practices that will help you create a reliable and accurate consignment accounting system.
Your consignment agreement is your single source of truth, so don't rush it. A strong contract sets clear expectations for both you (the consignor) and your seller (the consignee), preventing misunderstandings before they start. It should explicitly detail the pricing structure, how and when you’ll be paid for sold goods, and who is responsible if items are lost or damaged. Be sure to also outline the reporting frequency you expect from the consignee and the process for returning any unsold goods. A well-drafted agreement is the first and most critical step toward a smooth and profitable partnership.
Once your goods are with a consignee, you can’t afford to be out of the loop. Set up a system for regular monitoring to keep a firm handle on your inventory and sales. This means requiring frequent sales reports from your consignees so you always have an up-to-date picture of what’s been sold. It’s also smart to implement a process for regular inventory checks. Whether you use inventory software or conduct physical counts, comparing your records against the consignee's actual stock helps you catch discrepancies early and maintain accurate financial records.
Manually tracking sales and inventory across multiple consignees is a recipe for errors and delays. The right technology can automate this entire process, giving you real-time visibility without the manual effort. By integrating your systems, you can automatically pull sales data from your consignees, compare it against your own records, and ensure everything lines up. This not only saves time but also provides the accurate data you need for proper revenue recognition. Having seamless data integrations is key to creating a system that works for you, not against you.
One of the biggest challenges in consignment is managing the flow of information. You’re relying on your consignees for timely and accurate sales data, and things can get messy when you have inventory spread across different locations. Streamlining your data management with a centralized system is the solution. When all your sales, inventory, and commission data lives in one place, reporting becomes much simpler and more reliable. This allows you to close your books faster and make strategic decisions based on a complete and accurate view of your consignment operations.
Managing consignment revenue can feel like a constant juggling act. Between tracking inventory, verifying sales from consignees, and applying the right accounting rules, there are a lot of moving parts. Doing this all manually not only takes up valuable time but also opens the door to costly errors. This is where automation comes in. By implementing the right system, you can streamline the entire process, ensure compliance, and get a much clearer picture of your financial health.
Let’s be honest: manual data entry is tedious and prone to human error. When you’re dealing with complex consignment agreements, a simple typo or miscalculation can throw off your entire financial statement. Automating your revenue recognition process helps you achieve near-perfect accuracy, reducing the risk of compliance headaches with standards like ASC 606. More importantly, it frees your finance team from spending hours buried in spreadsheets. Instead, they can focus on strategic analysis and planning—the work that actually moves your business forward. You can find more insights on improving your financial operations on our blog.
Not all automation software is created equal, especially when it comes to consignment. You need a solution that can handle the specific complexities of your business. Look for a platform that automates the five-step model for ASC 606 compliance and can manage different revenue streams, from simple sales to product bundles. The right tool should process data in real-time, giving you an accurate, up-to-the-minute view of your revenue. It should also be flexible enough to adapt as your business grows and your consignment agreements evolve. Check out our pricing information to see what a comprehensive solution includes.
Adopting a new automation system is more than just installing software; it requires a thoughtful implementation plan. Before you begin, take the time to map out your current revenue recognition process. This helps you identify bottlenecks and establish repeatable, auditable workflows that your new system can support. A well-planned implementation ensures a smooth transition and sets you up for success from day one. The goal is to create a system that not only works for you now but also makes future audits much less stressful and costly. If you need help with this step, you can always schedule a demo with our team to talk through your specific needs.
To get the most out of automation, your revenue recognition software needs to play well with the other tools you already use. A solution that doesn’t connect to your existing systems just creates another data silo, forcing you back into manual data transfers. Look for a platform that offers seamless integrations with your ERP, CRM, and accounting software. This creates a single, unified source of truth for your financial data, eliminating repetitive tasks and ensuring everyone is working with the same information. When your systems communicate effectively, you gain clearer insights into your revenue streams and can make better strategic decisions.
How is a consignment sale different from a regular wholesale deal? The key difference comes down to who owns the inventory. In a wholesale deal, the retailer buys your products upfront, taking ownership immediately. You can recognize that revenue right away. With consignment, you retain ownership of your products even when they are in your partner's store. The sale is only recorded on your books when the final customer makes a purchase.
My consignee has my products. Can I count that as a sale yet? No, you can't. Simply sending your inventory to a consignee is just moving your assets from one location to another. Because you still own and control the goods, a sale hasn't occurred according to accounting standards like ASC 606. You can only recognize the revenue after your partner sells the product to an end customer.
What happens if a customer returns an item to my consignment partner? Since the original transaction is reversed, you'll need to adjust your books accordingly. The returned item goes back into your inventory, and you must reverse the revenue you previously recorded for that sale. This is why it's helpful to have a clear process for handling returns and to potentially hold a reserve for expected returns to keep your financial statements accurate.
Who is responsible for the inventory if it gets damaged or doesn't sell? As the consignor, you retain ownership of the goods until the final sale, which means you also carry the risk. If products are damaged at the consignee's location or simply fail to sell, the financial responsibility falls on you. This is a critical point to clarify in your consignment agreement and a major reason why revenue isn't recognized until the risk has been transferred to a final customer.
My partner's sales reports are often late or inaccurate. How can I get reliable data for my books? This is a common and frustrating challenge. The best solution is to move away from manual reporting and use technology to create a direct link between your systems. Integrating your accounting software with your consignee’s sales system provides a steady, accurate flow of data. This automation removes the guesswork and delays, ensuring you have the reliable information you need to recognize revenue correctly and on time.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Copyright © 2025 HubiFi | All rights reserved.
