Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Get a Demo
See your data in HubiFi < 2 days
Learn how to account for breakage gift card revenue, stay compliant, and use best practices to manage unredeemed gift card balances for your business.
Your gift card program generates more than just sales; it creates a rich dataset that can sharpen your entire financial strategy. While the primary goal is to properly account for breakage gift card revenue, the insights hidden within your redemption data are just as valuable. By analyzing when, where, and how customers use their cards—and when they don't—you can build more accurate revenue forecasts, identify trends in consumer behavior, and even develop targeted marketing campaigns to re-engage customers with outstanding balances. This guide will show you how to look beyond the compliance requirements and use your breakage data as a strategic asset to make smarter, data-driven decisions that support long-term growth.
If you’ve ever found a forgotten gift card in a drawer with a few dollars left on it, you’ve been a part of gift card breakage. It’s a common scenario, and for businesses, it represents a unique stream of revenue. Simply put, gift card breakage is the value of gift cards that are sold but never fully redeemed by customers.
When you sell a gift card, you receive cash upfront, creating a liability on your books because you owe the customer goods or services in the future. But what happens when that future never comes? That’s where breakage comes in. Instead of an outstanding liability, that unused value can eventually be recognized as revenue, directly impacting your financial statements. Understanding how to account for this is key to maintaining accurate books and a clear picture of your company’s performance.
Breakage revenue is the income a business recognizes from the portion of gift card sales that it doesn't expect customers to redeem. Think of it as payment for goods or services that you ultimately don't have to deliver. According to accounting principles, this happens when customers pay for something but don't exercise all of their rights—in this case, the right to redeem the full value of their gift card.
Instead of letting that value sit as a liability on your balance sheet forever, accounting standards allow you to recognize it as revenue. This is based on a reasonable expectation that a certain percentage of gift cards will go unused. The process involves analyzing historical data to predict how much will likely be left on the table, allowing you to convert that liability into profit in a compliant way.
It might seem strange that people would leave free money unspent, but it happens all the time. A significant percentage of gift cards go partially or fully unused every year for a handful of very human reasons. Many customers simply forget they have a gift card tucked away in their wallet or a desk drawer. Others might lose the physical card or delete the email with the digital code.
Sometimes, the remaining balance is so small that a customer decides it’s not worth the effort to make another purchase. In other cases, the redemption process itself can be a barrier. If your store has limited locations or a clunky online checkout, customers may give up. While federal law requires most gift cards to be valid for at least five years, that’s still plenty of time for them to get lost in the shuffle of daily life.
Gift card breakage has a direct and positive impact on your cash flow. When a customer purchases a gift card, you receive the cash immediately, giving you working capital you can use for operations, inventory, or other business needs. At this point, the sale is recorded as a liability.
If the customer never redeems the card, you never have to provide the corresponding product or service. That means the initial cash you received becomes pure profit, with no associated cost of goods sold. This unclaimed revenue moves from a liability to income on your financial statements, strengthening your bottom line. Properly managing your revenue recognition for breakage ensures you can accurately reflect this financial gain and make more informed business decisions.
Calculating your gift card breakage rate isn't about pulling a number out of thin air. It’s a strategic estimate that directly impacts the accuracy of your financial statements. Getting it right is essential for recognizing revenue correctly and staying compliant with accounting standards like ASC 606. The goal is to develop a reliable method for determining what percentage of your gift card liability will likely never be redeemed, allowing you to recognize that amount as revenue. While it might sound complicated, it’s a manageable process when you break it down.
Think of it as a four-step approach that moves from simple historical analysis to more sophisticated forecasting. By looking at your own past performance, comparing it to industry trends, understanding the factors at play, and eventually using predictive models, you can build a clear and defensible breakage rate. This process not only supports your accounting team but also provides valuable insights for your business. A well-calculated breakage rate means more accurate financial planning and a clearer picture of your company’s performance. It transforms a compliance task into a strategic advantage, helping you understand customer behavior and manage cash flow more effectively. Let’s walk through how you can approach this calculation methodically.
Your own sales history is the best place to start. Look back at your gift card data from the last five to ten years to identify patterns. The key is to compare the value of gift cards sold against the value redeemed within specific periods. This will show you the historical rate at which customers use their cards. For example, you might find that, on average, 8% of gift card value is never touched. If your business is new, you don't have this history to lean on. In that case, a common practice is to start with a conservative estimate of 5-10% and adjust it over time as you collect more of your own data.
If you’re a new business without years of data, you’re not just guessing. You can turn to industry benchmarks to establish a reasonable starting point. Look for reports and data from businesses similar to yours in size and sector. For instance, the breakage rate for a coffee shop might be different from that of a high-end electronics retailer. This approach gives your initial estimate credibility and ensures it’s grounded in reality, not just a hunch. Using information from similar companies is a widely accepted practice for your first year of operations, giving you a solid foundation until you’ve built up your own historical data.
The numbers only tell part of the story. To refine your estimate, you need to understand why some gift cards go unused. Several factors can influence your breakage rate. Low-value cards (e.g., $5 or $10) are more likely to be forgotten than high-value ones. Digital gift cards might have different redemption patterns than physical cards. Even your industry plays a role—a daily-use service will likely see lower breakage than a specialty store. Understanding these drivers helps you contextualize your data and explain why your breakage rate is what it is. This unspent money, or "breakage," is a direct result of these customer behaviors.
For the most accurate forecasting, you can use predictive modeling. This method goes beyond looking at past averages and uses statistical techniques to predict future redemption patterns. A predictive model can account for seasonality, recent sales trends, and other variables to give you a more dynamic and precise breakage estimate. This allows you to more accurately forecast your company's income and prepare for shifts in customer habits throughout the year. While it requires more sophisticated data analysis, the payoff is greater accuracy in your financial reporting. Solutions that offer automated revenue recognition can simplify this process, ensuring your forecasts are both accurate and compliant.
Handling gift card revenue isn't as simple as just booking a sale. Specific accounting rules govern how and when you can recognize that income, especially the portion that never gets redeemed. Getting these rules right is essential for accurate financial reporting and staying compliant. Let's walk through the key principles you need to know to manage your gift card program effectively.
If you’ve been in business for a while, you might remember the old way of handling breakage. But things have changed. The introduction of ASC 606 created a new standard for revenue recognition that directly impacts gift cards. Before, you might have waited years to see if a card would be used. Now, the rules require you to recognize expected breakage revenue in proportion to when customers redeem their gift cards. This means you need a reliable system to estimate how much breakage you expect and recognize it sooner, rather than letting it sit as a liability on your books indefinitely.
So, when exactly do you get to count breakage as revenue? The key is that you can’t just wait for a gift card to expire. Under ASC 606, if you expect to be entitled to the unused funds, you must estimate the breakage amount and recognize it. This is based on the pattern of redemption. For example, as customers use their gift cards, you can recognize a proportional amount of the estimated breakage. This prevents companies from sitting on large liabilities for unexercised rights indefinitely. The standard requires you to have a clear, data-backed method for your estimation, which is why tracking historical gift card usage is so important.
When you first sell a gift card, the cash you receive isn't immediately counted as revenue. Instead, it’s recorded as a liability on your balance sheet, often under "deferred revenue." Think of it as money you owe your customer in the form of goods or services. As the customer redeems the gift card, you gradually move that amount from the liability column to the revenue column on your income statement. The same goes for breakage revenue. As you recognize breakage in line with redemptions, you reduce the deferred revenue liability and increase your recognized revenue, giving a more accurate picture of your company's performance.
Before you book all your breakage as profit, you need to check your state's laws. Many states have consumer protection rules around gift cards, and some consider unclaimed gift card funds to be abandoned property. These unclaimed property laws, also known as escheatment laws, may require you to remit the value of unused gift cards to the state after a certain period. The rules vary significantly from one state to another, with different dormancy periods and reporting requirements. Failing to comply can lead to audits and penalties, so it’s critical to understand the specific breakage) regulations where you do business.
Recognizing breakage revenue isn't just about following accounting standards; it's also about working through a web of state and local laws. Before you book a single dollar of breakage, you need to understand your legal obligations. Many states have specific rules about what you can and can’t do with unredeemed gift card balances. These regulations, often called unclaimed property or "escheat" laws, are designed to protect consumers and ensure that abandoned funds are handled properly. It's a common area where businesses, especially high-volume ones, can get tripped up if they aren't careful.
Ignoring these rules can lead to serious consequences, including hefty fines, penalties, and audits from state authorities. The complexity grows exponentially if you operate in multiple states, as each one has its own set of requirements, dormancy periods, and reporting deadlines. Getting this right means staying informed and having a system in place to track gift card activity accurately from the moment of sale. This is where having clean, accessible data becomes non-negotiable. With the right information at your fingertips, you can confidently manage compliance, make accurate financial projections, and avoid any unwelcome surprises from state regulators. It’s about turning a potential liability into a well-managed part of your revenue stream.
Before you can calculate breakage, your first step is to check your state’s laws on unclaimed property. Think of unclaimed property as a lost-and-found for money. When a customer doesn't use their gift card for a long time, the state may consider that balance "abandoned." Unclaimed property laws often require you to hand over that unused money to the government. The state then holds onto it until the rightful owner—your customer—claims it. Each state has different rules for what qualifies as abandoned and how long you have to report it, so it's crucial to know the specific requirements where you do business.
Many states have consumer protection laws that directly impact how you handle gift card breakage. These rules often mandate that businesses report and remit the value of unused gift cards to the state through a process called escheatment. This isn't just a suggestion; it's a legal requirement. By turning the funds over, you allow your customers to reclaim their money) directly from the state as unclaimed property. Failing to meet these reporting deadlines can result in audits and financial penalties, so it’s essential to have a clear process for identifying and remitting these balances on time.
Escheatment is the formal process of transferring unclaimed property, like the balance on a dormant gift card, to the state government. Each state sets its own "dormancy period," which is the length of time a gift card must go unused before its balance is considered abandoned and must be escheated. This period can range from two to seven years, depending on the state. It’s important to remember that escheatment rules are not optional. Your business is legally obligated to track, report, and remit these funds according to the specific guidelines of each state in which you operate.
Gift card accounting is complex precisely because the rules change from one state to the next. Properly managing your gift card program means you’re not just tracking sales and redemptions but also staying on top of revenue recognition rules, breakage policies, and promotional offers. Following state-specific guidelines ensures your financial statements are accurate and that you remain compliant with the law. Having a system that provides clear visibility into your data is key. With the right integrations and reporting tools, you can simplify compliance and focus on making strategic decisions for your business.
Managing breakage revenue isn't just about following the rules; it's about maintaining a clear and accurate picture of your company's financial health. When you have solid practices in place, you can recognize revenue confidently, pass audits without a hitch, and make smarter strategic decisions. It all comes down to being proactive and organized. By implementing a few key strategies, you can turn a complex accounting task into a streamlined process that supports your business growth. Let's walk through the four most important practices for getting breakage right.
Manually tracking gift card sales and redemptions in spreadsheets is a recipe for errors and wasted time. The right technology is a game-changer here. Using automated systems can make tracking gift cards and calculating breakage much easier and more accurate. Look for a solution that doesn't just track numbers but also connects with your other financial software. When your revenue recognition platform can seamlessly integrate with your accounting systems, ERPs, and CRMs, you eliminate data silos and ensure everyone is working with the same, up-to-date information. This creates a single source of truth for your financial data, which is essential for accurate reporting.
Your breakage rate isn't a "set it and forget it" number. Customer behavior changes, promotions come and go, and economic conditions shift—all of which can affect redemption patterns. Because of this, companies need to check and update their breakage estimates regularly, ideally every reporting period. This is especially important for long-term programs, like loyalty points that might never expire, as their redemption patterns can be less predictable. Consistently reviewing your estimates ensures your financial statements reflect the most current data, keeping your reporting accurate and compliant with ASC 606. It’s a routine that pays off in reliable financials.
Think of your documentation as the story of your breakage revenue. It needs to be clear, detailed, and easy for an auditor or a new team member to follow. Keeping good records of how customers use their gift cards and loyalty points is crucial for making accurate breakage estimates. Your documentation should include everything from initial gift card sales and redemption data to the methodology you used to calculate breakage. If you ever change your estimation method, be sure to document why you made the change and what the impact was. This creates a transparent audit trail that supports your financial reporting and demonstrates due diligence.
Strong internal controls are your best defense against errors and inconsistencies in breakage accounting. The goal is to create a system of checks and balances that ensures data integrity from sale to redemption. A great first step is to track gift card sales and redemptions carefully to accurately estimate breakage. This includes processes like regularly reconciling your gift card liability account with sales and redemption reports. You might also consider separating duties, so the person responsible for gift card sales isn't the same person reconciling the accounts. These controls help you catch discrepancies early and provide confidence in your financial numbers.
Your gift card program is more than just a sales channel; it's a rich source of data that can sharpen your financial strategy. By moving from passive observation to active optimization, you can improve revenue forecasting, strengthen compliance, and even build better customer relationships. It all starts with a clear plan for how you manage and interpret the data behind every card.
The first step is to get a handle on your numbers. Before you can track breakage effectively, you need to determine what percentage of your gift card portfolio is subject to escheatment laws. Once you understand your compliance obligations, you can start tracking gift card redemption value over time. This data reveals crucial patterns, like how quickly cards are used and which promotions drive redemptions. Analyzing these trends helps you make informed decisions instead of guessing. Digging into these insights is fundamental to building a smarter program that aligns with both your financial goals and legal requirements.
With solid historical data, you can stop reacting and start predicting. A predictive model for gift card breakage behavior allows you to more accurately forecast your company's income. This isn't just about knowing your potential breakage revenue; it's about preparing for trends in redemption habits throughout the year, like post-holiday spikes or seasonal lulls. This foresight helps with cash flow management and overall financial stability. An automated system that provides these analytics can transform your forecasting from a quarterly chore into a real-time strategic advantage. You can schedule a demo to see how this works.
A proactive risk management strategy protects your business from compliance headaches and financial surprises. Many businesses estimate and recognize gift card breakage income based on their historical redemption patterns. By formalizing this process, you create a consistent and defensible approach that stands up to audits. This involves establishing clear internal controls for how breakage is calculated and when it's recognized on your books. Having the right systems in place to integrate your data from sales to accounting is key. It ensures your breakage estimates are always based on the most current and accurate information available.
While breakage can feel like free revenue, an unredeemed gift card is also a missed opportunity to create a loyal customer. Instead of just waiting for cards to expire, you can use that data to encourage redemptions. Simple tactics like sending email or text reminders to customers with outstanding balances can be highly effective. You could also create targeted promotions to bring them back. These efforts not only reduce your liability but also re-engage customers and turn a simple financial metric into a powerful tool for building customer relationships.
Managing gift card breakage can feel like a puzzle, but it’s one you can definitely solve. While recognizing this extra revenue is great for your bottom line, it introduces a few common hurdles. You might be a new business struggling to make estimates without any past data, or maybe you’re tangled in the web of state-specific compliance laws. For others, the biggest headache is simply getting different software systems to talk to each other without manual data entry. And of course, everyone wants to make their financial forecasts as accurate as possible. The good news is that these challenges are manageable with the right approach. By breaking them down, you can create a clear process for handling breakage revenue that is both compliant and profitable. Let's walk through how to tackle each of these common issues one by one.
What do you do when you’re just starting out and have no sales history? It’s a classic chicken-and-egg problem. Without your own data, estimating your breakage rate feels like a shot in the dark. The best place to start is by looking at industry benchmarks. For example, a new restaurant can use forfeiture rate data from similar establishments to create a reasonable estimate for its first year. Many businesses in this position start with a conservative guess of 5% to 10%. Just remember, this is a temporary fix. The most important step is to begin meticulously tracking your own gift card sales and redemptions from day one so you can refine your estimates with real data as you grow.
Navigating the legal side of gift card breakage can be tricky, especially when it comes to unclaimed property laws, also known as escheatment. These regulations require businesses to hand over the value of unredeemed gift cards to the state after a certain period of dormancy. The catch is that every state has different rules, timelines, and reporting requirements. For a business operating in multiple states, this creates a complicated compliance landscape. Misinterpreting these laws can lead to audits and penalties. To stay on the right side of the rules, it’s wise to consult with a financial or legal expert who understands the specific unclaimed property laws in the states where you operate.
If you’re manually pulling gift card data from your point-of-sale system and trying to reconcile it in your accounting software, you know how frustrating and error-prone it can be. Disconnected systems are a major source of inaccurate breakage calculations and wasted hours. The solution is to connect your platforms. Using automated systems that offer seamless integrations with your existing financial software makes tracking gift cards and calculating breakage much easier and more accurate. When your sales, redemption, and accounting data flow automatically, you eliminate manual entry errors and get a real-time view of your liabilities and breakage revenue. This is a key part of maintaining ASC 606 compliance without the manual headache.
A good breakage estimate isn't a one-and-done calculation. It’s a living number that should get more accurate over time. The foundation of a strong estimate is your own historical data. The more you have—ideally, at least five years of sales and redemption information—the more reliable your forecast will be. As your business evolves, so will your customer behavior, which means your breakage rate can change. That’s why it’s so important to review and update your estimates regularly, at least once a year. Consistently refining your approach not only leads to more precise financial statements but also gives you clearer insights for strategic planning and decision-making.
Trying to manage gift card revenue without a dedicated system is like trying to balance your books with sticky notes—it’s messy, prone to errors, and simply won’t hold up under scrutiny. An effective tracking system is the foundation of a solid breakage revenue strategy. It’s what allows you to move from guessing to knowing, ensuring your financial statements are accurate and you’re staying on the right side of compliance rules. This isn't just a 'nice-to-have'; for high-volume businesses, it's a necessity for sustainable growth.
Setting up a reliable system to track gift card balances from the start is essential. This isn't just about having the numbers; it's about having the right numbers, accessible when you need them. A great system gives you a clear view of your liabilities, helps you accurately forecast breakage, and provides the documentation you need to pass an audit with confidence. It automates the tedious work so you can focus on what the data is telling you. Let’s walk through the key components of a system that truly works for your business.
The first step is to ditch the manual spreadsheets. The right software automates the entire lifecycle of a gift card, from sale to redemption to breakage recognition. Using automated systems can make tracking gift cards and calculating breakage much easier and more accurate, especially for high-volume businesses. Look for a platform that can handle complex calculations, apply your breakage rate consistently, and generate the journal entries you need. This not only saves countless hours but also dramatically reduces the risk of human error that can lead to misstated financials. Your software should be a tool that simplifies complexity, not one that adds another layer of it.
Your gift card software shouldn't be an island. For your data to be truly powerful, it needs to connect with your existing financial ecosystem. A system with robust integrations can sync seamlessly with your accounting software, ERP, and CRM. This creates a single source of truth, eliminating the need for manual data entry and reconciliation between different platforms. When your sales data flows directly into your general ledger, you get a real-time picture of your financial health. This connection is critical for closing your books quickly and making strategic decisions based on up-to-the-minute information.
Data is only useful if you can understand it. When choosing a system, make sure it offers good reports that show sales, redemption patterns, and outstanding liabilities. You need more than just a data dump; you need actionable insights. Look for platforms with customizable dashboards and reporting features that allow you to see trends over time. This data helps with accounting and also informs your marketing strategy. For example, understanding where and when cards are used can help you create more effective promotions. You can find more reporting tips and financial insights in the HubiFi Blog.
Handling gift card data means you’re also responsible for protecting financial information and complying with various regulations. Your tracking system must have strong security measures in place to protect against fraud and data breaches. It’s also crucial to be aware of state and federal laws regarding gift card expiration dates and escheatment, which is the process of turning over unclaimed property to the state. A reliable software partner will help you stay compliant with these rules, which can vary significantly by location. This protects both your business and your customers, building trust and safeguarding your reputation.
What's the first thing I should do if my business has never accounted for gift card breakage? Your first step should be to research your state's unclaimed property laws. Before you can recognize any breakage as revenue, you need to understand your legal obligations. Some states require you to turn over unused balances to the government, which means there's no breakage revenue to claim. Once you're clear on the rules, you can start gathering your historical sales and redemption data to build a reliable estimation model.
Is a high breakage rate a good thing for my business? It's a bit of a double-edged sword. Financially, a high breakage rate means you're recognizing revenue without the cost of providing goods or services, which certainly helps your bottom line. However, it also represents a missed opportunity to connect with a customer. A better approach is to encourage redemptions with reminders or special offers. This builds customer loyalty while still allowing you to compliantly recognize the breakage that naturally occurs.
Can I just recognize breakage revenue when a gift card expires? That used to be a common practice, but current accounting standards require a more proactive approach. Under ASC 606, you can't simply wait for a card to expire. Instead, you must estimate the total breakage you expect and recognize it proportionally as other customers redeem their gift cards. This method gives a more accurate and timely view of your company's financial performance.
What's the biggest mistake businesses make with unclaimed property laws? The most common mistake is assuming the laws are the same everywhere or that they don't apply. Each state has its own rules and "dormancy periods" for when a gift card balance is considered abandoned and must be turned over to the state. Ignoring these escheatment laws can lead to audits and significant penalties, so it's essential to understand the specific requirements for every state in which you operate.
Why is a dedicated tracking system better than just using spreadsheets? While a spreadsheet might work when you're small, it quickly becomes a source of errors and wasted time as your business grows. A dedicated system automates the entire process, tracking sales, redemptions, and liabilities in real time. It ensures your breakage calculations are consistent and accurate, and it can integrate with your other financial software. This saves countless hours and provides the clean documentation you need to feel confident during an audit.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Copyright © 2025 HubiFi | All rights reserved.
