Sign in
Get a Demo
Talk with an accountant.
Get clear, actionable guidance on material right revenue recognition under ASC 606, with practical tips for identifying and accounting for material rights.
Customer loyalty programs and special renewal discounts are great for business, but they can create real complexity for your accounting team. That 50% off voucher you offered a new client isn't just a future marketing expense; it's a material right with immediate accounting consequences. Under ASC 606, you have to treat it as a separate deliverable from the initial sale. This is the foundation of material right revenue recognition. You must allocate a portion of the initial payment to this future promise and defer that revenue until the customer uses it. Let's walk through how to handle these common scenarios.
When you make a sale, it seems simple: you get paid, you recognize the revenue. But what if the deal includes a promise for something later? That’s where the concept of a "material right" comes in. Under ASC 606, a material right is a promise to a customer for a future good or service at a discount that's significant enough to be considered a separate part of the initial sale. It’s more than just a standard marketing offer; it’s a valuable option that influenced the customer’s decision to buy from you. Understanding how to identify and account for these rights is crucial for keeping your financial reporting accurate and compliant. Let's break down what they are and how to spot them.
Think of a material right as a valuable IOU you give your customer. According to the ASC 606 revenue recognition standard, it’s an option for a customer to purchase additional goods or services in the future at a significant discount. The key here is that the customer wouldn't get this special deal without entering into the current contract. It’s a real incentive that adds value to their purchase. Because this future option has value, you can't just ignore it until the customer uses it. You have to account for it as a separate performance obligation from the very beginning.
So, what separates a material right from a regular marketing promotion? The main difference is exclusivity. Ask yourself: Is this offer available to any customer, or is it specific to the one who signed this contract? If any customer visiting your website could get the same discount, it’s likely just a standard customer option and not a material right. A material right provides a significant financial incentive that the customer would not have received otherwise. It’s this exclusivity and value that makes it a distinct part of the contract that needs its own accounting treatment.
Let's make this concrete. A classic example is customer loyalty points. When a customer earns points with a purchase, they're gaining a right to a future discount. Another common one is a discount voucher for a future purchase that’s substantially better than your usual offers. For instance, if your company typically runs a 10% off sale for all customers, but you give a specific customer a 50% off voucher for their next purchase as part of a larger deal, that extra 40% discount is the material right. Other examples include special renewal options on a subscription or credits toward future services that are only offered to current contract holders.
Figuring out what counts as a material right can feel like a puzzle, but it’s a critical step for accurate revenue recognition. It all comes down to carefully reading your customer contracts and knowing what to look for. A material right isn't just any discount or future offer; it's a specific, valuable promise you make to a customer that influences their decision to buy from you in the first place.
Think of it as an additional deliverable you've committed to. If you offer a customer an option to purchase more goods or services at a price they couldn't get otherwise, you've likely created a material right. This could be anything from a significant discount on future renewals to loyalty points that translate into real savings. The key is that this option is substantial enough to be considered a separate performance obligation under ASC 606 guidelines. Getting this part right sets the foundation for compliant accounting and gives you a clearer picture of your financial commitments.
To find a material right, you need to look for options that give a customer a benefit they wouldn't receive without entering into the contract. It’s more than a standard marketing promotion available to the general public. Ask yourself: Is this offer a key reason the customer signed with us?
Look for specific clauses in your contracts that grant things like:
If the offer is something special that incentivized the original sale, you're likely looking at a material right.
The "significance test" is a straightforward way to separate a material right from a simple marketing offer. The main question to ask is: Would the customer get this special offer if they hadn't signed the initial contract? If the answer is no, and the discount is more significant than what you’d typically offer other customers, it’s a material right.
For example, if you offer a 10% discount to any first-time buyer, that’s just a marketing tactic. But if a contract gives a specific customer a 50% discount on their next purchase because they committed to a year-long plan, that discount is significant and exclusive. It has real value and is directly tied to the initial agreement, making it a material right that needs to be accounted for separately.
Once you identify a material right, clear documentation is essential for compliance and auditing. Your contract should explicitly state the terms of the right. Treat the material right as its own distinct promise to the customer, separate from the initial product or service you’re providing. This means it should be listed as a separate performance obligation.
Having a clear record ensures that everyone, from your sales team to your accountants, is on the same page. It also creates a transparent audit trail. Proper documentation is a cornerstone of good financial governance and helps you maintain accurate records, which is why keeping your data organized is so important for long-term financial health and strategic planning.
Once you’ve identified a material right in a contract, you can’t just treat it like a standard marketing discount. Under ASC 606, these rights have specific accounting rules because they represent a distinct promise to your customer. Think of it this way: the customer paid for both the initial product and the option to get something valuable later. Your accounting needs to reflect both of these promises.
This means you have to separate the material right from the other goods or services in the contract and treat it as its own performance obligation. A portion of the initial payment from the customer must be allocated to this future promise. You can't recognize all the revenue upfront. Instead, you defer the portion related to the material right until the customer either redeems their option or it expires. This ensures your financial statements accurately reflect the value you still owe to your customer, keeping you in line with ASC 606 compliance. Getting this right is crucial for accurate revenue reporting and a clear picture of your company's financial health.
A material right creates an additional performance obligation. In simple terms, it’s another promise you have to fulfill for the customer. It’s not just a potential discount; it’s a tangible benefit the customer wouldn't have received otherwise, and it influenced their decision to buy from you in the first place. Because it’s a separate promise, it needs to be accounted for separately. You have to assign a portion of the transaction price to this obligation, just as you would for the primary product or service in the contract. This ensures that you recognize revenue as you satisfy each distinct promise to your customer.
When a contract includes a material right, you must allocate the total transaction price between the initial goods or services and the material right itself. You can’t recognize 100% of the cash received from the sale immediately. Instead, you have to determine the standalone selling price of the material right and set that amount aside. This process ensures your revenue recognition is timed correctly. The portion of revenue allocated to the material right is deferred and only recognized when the customer exercises their option (e.g., uses the discount) or when the option expires. This allocation is fundamental to properly reflecting your earned revenue over the life of the contract.
The accounting rules for material rights directly impact your balance sheet and income statement. When you allocate a portion of the initial sale to a material right, that amount is recorded as deferred revenue—a liability on your balance sheet. It represents the obligation you have to your customer for a future purchase. This liability stays on your books until the customer redeems the right, at which point you can move it from deferred revenue to recognized revenue on your income statement. If the right expires unused, you can also recognize the revenue at that time. This process prevents you from overstating your revenue and provides a more accurate view of your company's financial performance.
Once you’ve identified a material right, you need to figure out its standalone selling price (SSP). This is the price a customer would pay for that right if it were sold separately. Think of it as assigning a specific value to the future discount or offer. This value is crucial because it determines how much revenue you defer from the initial sale.
While it might sound like guesswork, ASC 606 provides a few reliable methods for estimating the SSP. You don’t have to use all of them; the goal is to choose the one that best reflects the value of the right for your specific situation. Having a clear, documented process for this is key to staying compliant and ensuring your financial statements are accurate. Let’s walk through the three most common approaches you can use.
The adjusted market assessment approach is all about looking outward. To use this method, you evaluate what customers in the market would be willing to pay for a similar right. This could involve looking at what your competitors charge for comparable offers or even what you might charge for that option if it were a standalone product.
For example, if the material right is a 50% discount on a future purchase, you’d consider the typical price of the products it applies to and the likelihood of a customer using it. You’re essentially asking, "What is the market value of this promise?" This approach requires a good understanding of your market and customer base to arrive at a reasonable and defensible price.
If a clear market comparison isn't available, you can turn inward and use the expected cost plus margin approach. This method involves calculating the costs you expect to incur to fulfill the material right and then adding a normal profit margin. It’s a "cost-plus" calculation that builds the price from the ground up.
Let's say the right is for a free service add-on. You would calculate the direct costs of providing that service—like labor and materials—and then add the standard margin you make on your services. This approach is particularly useful for unique offers that don't have a direct equivalent in the market, allowing you to base the SSP on your own financial structure.
Your own historical data is one of the most powerful tools you have. By analyzing past customer behavior, you can estimate the value of a material right based on how often customers have used similar offers before. Look at the redemption rates for past promotions to predict the likelihood that customers will exercise the current right.
For instance, if you’ve offered a similar discount in the past and only 20% of eligible customers used it, you can factor that probability into your SSP calculation. This data-driven approach provides strong evidence for your valuation. Having robust systems that allow for seamless integrations makes pulling this kind of historical data much simpler, giving you a clearer picture of customer habits and a more accurate SSP.
Once you've identified a material right in a contract, the next step is to account for it correctly. Following the ASC 606 framework, this process breaks down into three clear stages. It’s all about making sure you recognize revenue at the right time—not too early and not too late. This approach ensures your financial statements accurately reflect the value you’ve delivered to the customer and what you still owe them. Getting this right is fundamental for maintaining ASC 606 compliance and providing a true picture of your company's financial health. Let’s walk through each step so you can handle material rights with confidence.
First, you need to look at the initial sale. Start by confirming you have a clear contract with your customer that spells out the material right. Then, identify all the distinct promises you've made, which are your performance obligations. In this case, you have at least two: the original product or service the customer bought, and the material right for a future discount. The material right isn't just a marketing gimmick; it's a separate promise you need to fulfill. Finally, you'll allocate the total transaction price across these obligations. This means you have to assign a portion of the initial payment to the material right based on its standalone selling price.
Since the material right represents a promise for a future good or service, you can't recognize the revenue for it immediately. Instead, you need to defer it. Think of it as setting aside the portion of the customer's payment that you allocated to the material right in Step 1. This deferred revenue is recorded on your balance sheet as a liability. It signals that you still owe your customer something of value. This step is crucial for accurate reporting because it prevents you from overstating your revenue in the current period. You'll hold onto this deferred revenue until the customer takes action.
The final step is to actually recognize the revenue you set aside. This happens at one of two points: when the customer exercises their right (for example, by redeeming their loyalty points or using their discount on a new purchase) or when the right expires. If the customer uses the option, you recognize the revenue because you have fulfilled your promise. If they don't use it and the option expires, you can also recognize the revenue at that time, as your obligation is now complete. Tracking these events manually can be a headache, which is why many businesses use automated solutions that offer seamless data integrations to monitor customer activity.
So, what happens when a customer finally decides to use that special discount or offer you gave them? This is where your careful deferral work pays off. When a material right is exercised, you don't just record a new sale. Instead, you'll update your books to reflect that the customer is cashing in on a value you've already accounted for. It’s a multi-step process that connects the new purchase back to the original one.
Think of it as closing a loop. The customer took an action based on a previous transaction, and your accounting needs to show that connection clearly. Properly handling exercised rights ensures your revenue is recognized at the right time and in the right amount, keeping your financial statements accurate and compliant with ASC 606. Getting this right is crucial for maintaining a clear picture of your company's performance and avoiding headaches during an audit. Let's walk through the specific steps you need to take.
The moment a customer uses their material right—whether it's a discount on a future purchase or a free add-on—you need to record it. This isn't just another line item in your sales journal. You should treat the exercise of the right as a new transaction that is directly linked to the initial contract.
Essentially, the customer is creating a new order for additional goods or services. The key difference is that part of the payment for this new order was already made, in a sense, when you allocated a portion of the original transaction price to the material right. Accounting standards give you a couple of ways to handle this, but the most straightforward approach is to treat it as a new contract, which keeps your records clean and easy to follow.
This is where your deferred revenue account comes into play. When the customer exercises their right, you’ll take the amount you initially deferred for that material right and combine it with the new cash payment from the customer. This total becomes the transaction price for the newly delivered goods or services. For example, if a customer pays $40 to use a 50% off voucher (for an $80 item) and you had deferred $10 for that voucher, the total revenue you recognize for this new transaction is $50 ($40 cash + $10 deferred revenue). This process can get complicated with high-volume sales, which is why many businesses rely on automated revenue recognition to handle these adjustments accurately.
Finally, you need to update the status of your performance obligations. The material right itself has now been satisfied, so you can mark that performance obligation as complete. The new goods or services that the customer just purchased now represent a new, fulfilled performance obligation. By treating the exercise as a new transaction, you create a clear and simple audit trail. This method is generally preferred by accountants because it avoids complex recalculations and reallocations within the original contract. Keeping your records updated in real-time is essential for accurate financial reporting and provides valuable accounting insights into customer behavior and the effectiveness of your promotions.
Accounting for material rights sounds straightforward on paper, but putting it into practice can feel like a puzzle. The main hurdles aren't just about understanding the rules—they're about dealing with future uncertainties and managing complex data. Many businesses find it tricky to accurately predict what their customers will do, track all the moving parts, and apply the rules consistently without the right systems in place.
The core of the issue is that material rights create a performance obligation that extends beyond the initial sale. You've promised your customer something valuable in the future, and you have to account for that promise today. This involves estimating the value of that right and deferring the corresponding revenue until the customer either uses their option or lets it expire. Getting this wrong can lead to misstated financials and compliance headaches. For more guidance on complex accounting topics, you can find helpful articles on the HubiFi blog. Let's break down the most common challenges you'll likely face.
One of the biggest challenges is figuring out the standalone selling price of a material right. Since you don't typically sell these options separately—like a 50% off coupon for a future purchase—you have to estimate their value. This often means looking at historical data to see how customers have behaved in the past. But the real difficulty is predicting how many customers will actually redeem their offer. Will 20% of them use that coupon, or will it be closer to 60%? Your initial estimate is just a starting point, and you’ll need to update it as you gather more data on customer redemption patterns.
Once you have your estimates, you need a reliable way to track everything. This isn't something you can easily manage in a simple spreadsheet, especially if you're dealing with a high volume of transactions. You must track the deferred revenue associated with each material right and recognize it only when the right is exercised or expires. This requires robust systems that can handle complex calculations and monitor customer behavior over time. Having seamless integrations with HubiFi can connect your sales and accounting platforms, ensuring your data is always accurate and up-to-date without manual effort.
To stay compliant and maintain accurate financial records, consistency is key. You need to apply your chosen accounting method across all similar customer options and contracts. Some approaches, like the practical alternative for accounting for unexercised rights, can be particularly complex. It's always a good idea to consult with accounting professionals to ensure you're interpreting and applying the guidance correctly. For those who want to explore the technical details, it's helpful to understand exactly how the customer’s exercise of a material right is treated under ASC 606. This ensures you're not just compliant, but also confident in your financial reporting.
Managing material rights effectively is all about having a solid game plan. Without clear procedures, you risk inaccurate financial statements and compliance headaches. By putting a few key practices in place, you can handle these complex obligations with confidence and precision, ensuring your revenue recognition is always on point. These strategies will help you build a reliable framework for identifying, valuing, and accounting for material rights from start to finish.
Let’s be honest: figuring out the standalone value of a material right can feel like a guessing game. Since it’s not an item you typically sell on its own, you have to estimate its price based on historical data and market trends. Your best bet is to create a strong estimation model using past customer behavior, redemption rates for similar offers, and any other relevant data you have. It's also crucial to track the costs associated with offering these future benefits and match them to the revenue you recognize when the rights are used or expire. For more expert advice on financial modeling, you can find helpful articles on the HubiFi Blog.
Material rights aren't just a finance problem—they're a company-wide reality. Your sales and marketing teams are on the front lines, and they have the best insights into why a customer might use a discount or what promotions are likely to drive behavior. Working closely with these departments helps ground your financial estimates in what’s actually happening with your customers. This collaboration is much smoother when your data flows freely between departments. Having seamless integrations between your CRM, billing, and accounting systems ensures everyone is working from the same playbook, leading to more accurate assessments.
Customer habits and market conditions are always shifting, which means your initial assumptions about material rights might not hold true forever. This isn't a set-it-and-forget-it task. You need to regularly review your data and update your accounting based on new information to keep your financials accurate. While your estimates may change over time, the method you use to arrive at them should be applied consistently for similar contracts to ensure compliance. Staying on top of these changes manually can be tough, but it's essential for accurate reporting. Seeing how automation can streamline this process might give you a clearer picture of what’s possible when you schedule a demo.
Trying to manage material rights with spreadsheets and manual processes is a recipe for headaches. Between tracking customer options across different contracts, predicting when they’ll be used, and staying compliant with ASC 606, it’s easy for things to fall through the cracks. This is especially true for high-volume businesses where thousands of transactions happen every day. Manual tracking isn’t just slow—it’s risky, opening the door to errors that can misstate revenue and cause major issues during an audit.
This is where automation changes the game. By implementing an automated revenue recognition solution, you can take the guesswork and manual labor out of managing material rights. Instead of spending hours reconciling data, your team can focus on strategic analysis. An automated system can identify potential material rights as soon as a contract is signed, track their usage in real-time, and ensure every dollar is recognized correctly. It simplifies the entire process by connecting your data, enforcing accounting rules consistently, and giving you a clear view of your financial obligations at all times.
One of the biggest challenges with material rights is simply keeping track of them all. An automated system can scan new contracts and sales orders for terms that indicate a material right, like "free future service" or "discount on next purchase." By setting up rules, the platform can automatically flag these options and create the necessary accounting entries without any manual work.
From there, the system monitors each customer’s activity. When a customer exercises their right, the platform records the transaction and triggers the correct revenue recognition schedule. If the option expires, it’s handled automatically, too. This continuous, hands-off tracking eliminates the risk of human error and ensures your deferred revenue balances are always accurate. You can find more insights in the HubiFi blog on how automation streamlines complex accounting.
When auditors come knocking, you need to be able to prove your material rights accounting is compliant with ASC 606. Pulling together manual reports can take days or even weeks, and by the time you’re done, the data is already outdated. Automation gives you access to real-time compliance reports with the click of a button.
Because the system tracks every material right from creation to expiration, it can instantly generate detailed reports on deferred revenue, recognized revenue, and outstanding performance obligations. This gives you a clear and current picture of your financial position. Having this data on hand not only makes audits smoother but also empowers you to make better strategic decisions based on accurate, up-to-the-minute information. You can schedule a demo with HubiFi to see how automated reporting works.
Your data on material rights is likely scattered across multiple systems—your CRM holds the contract details, your billing platform processes the transactions, and your ERP manages the financials. Without integration, your team is stuck manually piecing this information together. This is not only inefficient but also leads to data discrepancies.
An automated solution connects these disparate systems, creating a single source of truth for all your revenue data. When your platforms can communicate seamlessly, you get a complete view of the entire customer lifecycle and its financial impact. This holistic perspective ensures that nothing is missed and that your revenue recognition for material rights is consistently accurate across the board. Strong integrations with HubiFi ensure all your financial tools work together perfectly.
How can I tell if a discount is a "material right" or just a normal marketing promotion? The simplest way to distinguish between the two is to ask yourself if the offer is exclusive. If any customer could get the same discount without signing the specific contract in question, it's likely a standard marketing offer. A material right, however, is a special deal the customer only gets because they entered into the current agreement, and it's significant enough to have influenced their decision to buy.
What happens if I estimate the value of a material right incorrectly? Your initial valuation is an estimate, and it’s understood that it might not be perfect. The important thing is to have a reasonable, documented basis for your calculation. As you gather more data on how customers actually use these rights, you should review and adjust your estimates. This shows you're making a good-faith effort to keep your financial reporting accurate over time.
Do I really need to account for small customer loyalty points or minor discounts? This comes down to the principle of materiality. If the total value of the points or discounts is truly insignificant to your company's overall financial picture, the accounting effort might not be necessary. However, for loyalty programs that offer substantial value and influence customer behavior, you absolutely need to account for them properly. It's wise to set a clear internal policy on what your company considers a significant offer.
When does a material right officially "expire"? The expiration depends entirely on the terms you set in the contract or offer. It could be a specific date, like a voucher that is only valid for 90 days. For other rights, like loyalty points, the expiration might be tied to customer inactivity, such as 12 months without a purchase. The key is to define these terms clearly so you know exactly when your obligation to the customer has ended.
My business is still small. Is this something I really need to worry about now? Yes, it's a great idea to get this right from the start. Establishing correct accounting practices early on sets a strong foundation for growth. It ensures your financial reports are accurate, which is crucial for making sound business decisions, securing loans, or attracting investors. Handling it correctly now prevents a much larger and more complicated cleanup project down the road.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Meet with an expert in revenue recognition and order-to-cash accounting and automate revenue close.
*Or watch 2 minute demo here.
Power your high-volume business's revenue compliance and reporting needs with one platform.
