Sign in
Get a Demo
Talk with an accountant.
Get clear on the ASC 606 revenue recognition 5 steps with practical tips for financial professionals. Ensure accurate, audit-ready financial reporting.
Getting revenue recognition right is non-negotiable. Make a mistake, and you could face failed audits, financial restatements, and a serious loss of investor trust. The stakes are high. Thankfully, the ASC 606 standard isn't just a set of rules—it's a clear playbook for success. This guide breaks down the essential asc 606 revenue recognition 5 steps into simple, actionable terms. We'll walk through the complete 5 step revenue recognition model, giving you the confidence to know your financials are accurate and audit-proof.
Before we jump into the five-step model, it’s helpful to get a clear picture of what ASC 606 is and why it was created. Think of it as the universal language for reporting revenue. It was established to clear up the confusion caused by different industries following different rules, making financial statements more reliable and comparable for everyone involved, from investors to internal teams.
At its core, ASC 606 provides a single, comprehensive framework for recognizing revenue. It gives companies clear steps on how to report income from customer contracts, with the main goal being to show exactly when a company transfers goods or services to a customer. This shift ensures that revenue is recorded when it's truly earned, not just when the cash comes in. By standardizing the process, the framework helps businesses present a more accurate and consistent financial story, which builds trust and simplifies analysis across different companies and industries.
While ASC 606 applies to nearly all businesses that have contracts with customers, it’s especially critical for certain types. Public companies and large private businesses with over $25 million in annual sales are legally required to follow it. However, compliance is also essential for startups seeking funding and any business with complex revenue streams, like subscriptions or bundled services. For high-volume companies managing thousands of transactions, manually tracking these complex contracts can be overwhelming. This is where having a system for automated revenue recognition becomes a game-changer, ensuring you stay compliant without slowing down your growth.
Unlike older, rigid, rules-based standards, ASC 606 is principles-based. This means it provides a core set of principles rather than a checklist of specific rules for every possible scenario. The standard requires companies to use professional judgment to apply the five-step model to their unique customer contracts. While this approach offers more flexibility, it also places a greater responsibility on businesses to interpret the principles correctly and document their reasoning. Having clean, organized, and accessible data is crucial for making sound judgments and confidently defending your revenue recognition policies during an audit.
A contract is an agreement between two or more parties that creates enforceable rights and obligations. To recognize revenue, a company must first identify the contract with the customer. This step is fundamental because it sets the stage for the subsequent steps in the revenue recognition process.
To identify a contract under ASC 606, the following criteria must be met:
Approval and Commitment: All parties to the contract must approve the agreement and be committed to fulfilling their respective obligations. This can be in the form of written, verbal, or implied agreements, provided they are legally enforceable.
Identifiable Rights: The rights of each party regarding the goods or services to be transferred must be identifiable. This means that the contract should clearly outline what the customer can expect to receive and what the company is obligated to deliver.
Payment Terms: The payment terms for the goods or services to be transferred must be identifiable. This includes the amount of consideration and the timing of payment.
Commercial Substance: The contract must have commercial substance, meaning that the risk, timing, or amount of the company’s future cash flows is expected to change as a result of the contract.
Probable Collection: It must be probable that the company will collect the consideration to which it will be entitled in exchange for the goods or services transferred to the customer.
Identifying the contract is crucial because it ensures that revenue is recognized only when there is a legally enforceable agreement. This step helps prevent the premature recognition of revenue and ensures that financial statements accurately reflect the company's financial position.
In practice, identifying a contract may involve several considerations:
Multiple Contracts: Sometimes, multiple contracts with the same customer are negotiated as a package with a single commercial objective. In such cases, these contracts should be combined and accounted for as a single contract.
Contract Modifications: If there are modifications to the contract, these changes need to be evaluated to determine if they should be treated as a separate contract or as part of the existing contract.
Implied Contracts: In some cases, a contract may not be in writing but can still be enforceable based on the conduct of the parties. Companies need to assess whether such implied contracts meet the criteria for revenue recognition.
While this article focuses on the first step, it's essential to understand the remaining steps in the revenue recognition model:
Performance obligations are the distinct goods or services that a company promises to deliver to the customer. This step involves determining what the company is obligated to provide under the contract. Each performance obligation must be identifiable and distinct from others.
So, what exactly makes a promise to your customer "distinct"? Under ASC 606, a good or service qualifies as distinct if two specific criteria are met. First, the customer can benefit from the item either on its own or with other resources they already have. Second, your promise to provide that item is separately identifiable from other promises in the contract. For instance, if you sell a software subscription along with a one-time installation service, these are likely two distinct performance obligations. The customer benefits from the software on its own, and the installation is a separate, identifiable service. Correctly identifying these obligations is crucial because it directly impacts how and when you recognize revenue for each part of the agreement, ensuring your financials are accurate.
The transaction price is the amount of consideration (payment) that a company expects to receive in exchange for transferring goods or services to the customer. This step requires assessing the likelihood of collectibility and considering any variable components, such as discounts or incentives.
Sometimes, the price isn't a simple flat fee. Variable consideration refers to any part of the payment that can change based on future events. Think of things like discounts, rebates, refunds, credits, or performance bonuses. These elements can make the transaction price a moving target. Under ASC 606, you can't just wait and see what happens; you have to estimate the amount of this variable consideration when you first set up the contract. This means looking at all the potential outcomes and figuring out the amount of revenue you truly expect to earn from the deal. It’s a crucial step to ensure you’re not overstating your initial revenue.
The tricky part is that ASC 606 includes a constraint: you can only include variable consideration in the transaction price if it's probable that a significant revenue reversal won’t happen later. To figure out this amount, you can use one of two methods: the expected value (best for a large number of similar contracts) or the most likely amount (best when there are only two possible outcomes). For businesses with high transaction volumes, manually calculating this for every contract is a huge challenge. This is where automated revenue recognition becomes a lifesaver, ensuring each contract is assessed correctly without tying up your finance team for weeks. It helps you handle these estimates accurately and consistently, which is key for compliance.
Once the transaction price is determined, it must be allocated to the identified performance obligations based on their relative standalone selling prices. This allocation ensures that revenue is recognized in a manner that reflects the transfer of goods or services to the customer.
Revenue is recognized when control of the goods or services is transferred to the customer. This can occur at a point in time or over time, depending on the nature of the performance obligation. The timing of revenue recognition is critical for accurate financial reporting.
This final step is all about timing. Revenue is recognized when your customer gains control of the goods or services, which happens either "at a point in time" or "over time." A point-in-time transfer is simple: think of a retail sale where control passes immediately. In contrast, recognizing revenue over time applies to ongoing services, like a software subscription, where the customer benefits continuously. For these types of obligations, you need to measure progress toward completion using methods like milestones or costs incurred. The nature of the performance obligation determines the timing, a key principle in ASC 606. This gets tricky for businesses with complex contracts that blend both delivery types, making it difficult to track and recognize revenue accurately without solid processes or automated systems in place.
What is revenue recognition?
Why is the five-step model important?
What are performance obligations?
How is the transaction price determined?
When is revenue recognized?
What are the implications of not following the revenue recognition standards?
How do different industries apply the five-step model?
What are the common challenges companies face in revenue recognition?
How do changes in contracts affect revenue recognition?
One of the first questions to ask is whether your company is acting as a principal or an agent in a transaction. This distinction is critical because it directly impacts how much revenue you report on your income statement. A company is a principal if it controls the good or service before it's transferred to the customer. In this case, you report the full amount of the sale as revenue. On the other hand, a company is an agent if its role is simply to arrange for another party to provide the good or service. As an agent, you only report the net commission or fee you earn as revenue. Think of it as the difference between a retail store selling its own inventory versus a travel agency booking a flight on an airline.
What about the costs you incur to win or fulfill a contract? Things like sales commissions or initial setup fees can be significant. Under ASC 606, certain costs to obtain or fulfill a contract can be recorded as an asset on your balance sheet instead of being expensed immediately. This asset is then amortized, or spread out, over the period that the related goods or services are transferred to the customer. The key condition is that these costs must be recoverable and are expected to create future benefits. Managing these amortization schedules manually can be a headache, which is why many businesses use automated systems to ensure compliance and accuracy. If you're struggling with this, it might be time to schedule a demo to see how automation can help.
Beyond the main five steps, ASC 606 provides specific instructions for situations that pop up all the time in business. These rules help apply the principles-based framework to tangible, everyday transactions. Let's look at a few of the most common ones.
For software and technology companies, the distinction between different types of licenses is huge. A "right to use" license gives the customer the right to use your intellectual property as it exists at the moment of transfer, like when they download a piece of software. Revenue for this is typically recognized at a single point in time. In contrast, a "right to access" license involves ongoing service, updates, and support, like a cloud-based SaaS subscription. For these, revenue must be recognized over the duration of the contract. Getting this right requires clean data from all your systems, so ensuring you have seamless integrations is a must.
Many products come with a warranty, but not all warranties are treated the same for accounting purposes. An assurance-type warranty, which is your standard promise that a product will function as intended, is not a separate performance obligation. Its costs are simply accrued as an expense. However, a service-type warranty, like an optional extended warranty that a customer can purchase, is considered a distinct service. This makes it a separate performance obligation, and the revenue from it must be recognized over the coverage period, not all at once when the customer pays for it.
What about loyalty points, renewal options, or other discounts you offer customers for future purchases? Under ASC 606, if these options provide a "material right" that the customer wouldn't receive otherwise, they are considered a separate performance obligation. This means you have to allocate a portion of the initial transaction price to that option. You'll need to estimate the likelihood that customers will redeem their points or use their discount and recognize that allocated revenue when they do. This adds another layer of complexity to tracking revenue, and you can find more insights on managing these challenges on our blog.
If you sell products that customers can return, you can't recognize the full sale amount as revenue right away. Instead, you must estimate the value of expected returns based on historical data and other relevant factors. The revenue you recognize at the time of sale is the total sale amount *minus* the estimated returns. You'll also need to record a corresponding liability for refunds and an asset for the right to recover the returned products. This process requires a solid handle on your data to make reasonable estimates, highlighting the importance of having a system that provides clear, real-time visibility into your sales and return patterns.
The introduction of ASC 606 did more than just change a few rules; it fundamentally altered how companies present their financial health. Its impact goes far beyond the income statement, reshaping the balance sheet and demanding a much higher level of detail in financial disclosures. This shift forces companies to provide a clearer, more comprehensive picture of their revenue streams and contractual obligations. For investors, stakeholders, and leadership, this means getting a more accurate story of how and when a company truly earns its money, which is essential for making informed decisions.
ASC 606 brings two key terms to the forefront of the balance sheet: contract assets and contract liabilities. A "contract asset" arises when you've fulfilled a performance obligation (i.e., done the work) but don't yet have an unconditional right to invoice the customer. Think of it as earned but not-yet-billable revenue. Conversely, a "contract liability" is created when a customer pays you before you've delivered the promised goods or services. This is what many used to call deferred revenue. The standard requires companies to present these items distinctly on their financial statements, providing a more transparent view of future revenue and outstanding obligations.
Beyond just rearranging the balance sheet, ASC 606 places a heavy emphasis on transparency through detailed disclosures. It’s no longer enough to simply report your top-line revenue number; you now have to explain the story behind it. The standard requires companies to provide both qualitative and quantitative information about their customer contracts. This includes breaking down revenue by category, showing changes in contract asset and liability balances, and explaining the significant judgments made in the process. The ultimate goal is to give anyone reading your financial reports a clear understanding of the nature, amount, timing, and uncertainty of your revenue streams.
While the five-step model provides a structured framework, putting it into practice can be a complex undertaking. Because ASC 606 is principles-based rather than rules-based, it leaves room for interpretation and requires significant professional judgment. These challenges are often amplified for high-volume businesses or companies with subscription-based models, where contracts are numerous and constantly evolving. Manually tracking performance obligations, allocating transaction prices, and managing contract modifications can quickly become a major operational bottleneck, introducing risks of error and non-compliance that can hinder growth and create audit headaches.
Relying on spreadsheets to manage ASC 606 compliance is like trying to build a skyscraper with a hammer and nails—it’s possible, but it's inefficient and incredibly risky. For any business with a significant number of transactions, manual tracking is a drain on resources and a breeding ground for errors. Each new contract, upgrade, or discount adds another layer of complexity that spreadsheets struggle to handle, making the month-end close a stressful, time-consuming ordeal. This is why forward-thinking finance teams adopt automated revenue recognition solutions that can handle the complexity and integrate with existing systems to ensure data flows smoothly and accurately.
One of the most demanding aspects of ASC 606 is the need to make, document, and defend significant judgments. For instance, determining the standalone selling price of each distinct performance obligation or estimating variable consideration often involves complex analysis. These aren't just internal exercises; the SEC pays close attention to how companies apply the standard, and auditors will scrutinize your methodologies. This regulatory oversight means you must have a consistent and defensible process for every judgment call. A robust, automated system provides the framework and audit trail necessary to support your decisions and help you prepare for audits with confidence.
A valid contract under ASC 606 must be approved by all parties, have identifiable rights and payment terms, possess commercial substance, and it must be probable that the company will collect the consideration.
Yes, verbal agreements can be considered contracts if they meet the criteria for enforceability and the terms are clear and agreed upon by all parties.
Contract modifications should be evaluated to determine if they constitute a separate contract or if they should be accounted for as part of the existing contract. This assessment ensures that revenue recognition remains accurate and compliant with ASC 606.
If a contract does not meet the criteria, revenue cannot be recognized until the criteria are met. Companies must continue to assess the contract to determine when it becomes enforceable and eligible for revenue recognition.
Implied contracts, based on the conduct of the parties, must be assessed to determine if they meet the criteria for enforceability. If they do, they should be treated as valid contracts for revenue recognition purposes.
By understanding the five steps of revenue recognition, businesses can ensure compliance with accounting standards and provide accurate financial information to stakeholders. This structured approach not only enhances transparency but also builds trust with investors and customers alike.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Meet with an expert in revenue recognition and order-to-cash accounting and automate revenue close.
Talk with an accountant →*Or watch 2 minute demo here.
Power your high-volume business's revenue compliance and reporting needs with one platform.
