Sign in
Get a Demo
Talk with an accountant.
Get clear, practical steps for gift card revenue recognition, including breakage, compliance, and common mistakes to avoid for accurate financial reporting.
What happens to the money from gift cards that are never used? Many business owners assume it’s free profit, but it’s not that simple. That leftover value, known as "breakage," has to be accounted for in a specific way. Furthermore, many states have "escheatment" laws that may require you to turn over the value of long-forgotten gift cards to the government. Managing these unredeemed balances is a crucial, and often overlooked, part of proper gift card revenue recognition. Ignoring these rules can turn what seems like a windfall into a significant compliance risk. We’ll explain how to handle breakage and unclaimed property correctly.
When a customer buys a $100 gift card from your store, it feels like a win. You just made a sale, right? Well, not exactly. From an accounting perspective, you haven't earned that money yet. Instead, that $100 is considered "deferred revenue," which is a fancy way of saying it's a liability on your books. Think of it as a promise you've made to the customer—you owe them $100 worth of products or services in the future.
You can only recognize that money as actual sales revenue when the customer comes back and redeems the gift card. This is the core principle of gift card revenue recognition, and it’s a crucial part of staying compliant with accounting standards like ASC 606. While the concept seems straightforward, the process gets complicated when you factor in things like partially used cards, unredeemed balances, and state-specific laws. For businesses with high sales volume, manually tracking each gift card's journey from liability to revenue can quickly become a major headache, leading to inaccurate financial reports and compliance risks.
Gift cards introduce a few unique challenges to your accounting process. First, there's the issue of "breakage"—the portion of gift card funds that customers never redeem. While you can eventually recognize this breakage as income, you have to follow specific rules to estimate and record it properly. Then there are escheatment laws, which vary by state and may require you to turn over the value of unredeemed gift cards to the state after a certain period. This adds another layer of compliance you need to monitor. The accounting entries themselves also require careful management: a sale increases cash and deferred revenue, while a redemption decreases deferred revenue and increases sales revenue.
The way you handle gift cards has a direct impact on your financial statements. When you sell a gift card, your cash balance goes up, but so does your liability for deferred revenue. Your income statement remains unchanged until the card is actually used. This timing difference is critical for accurate reporting. On the plus side, gift card sales give your cash flow a nice, immediate injection of funds without you having to pay interest. However, it's essential to remember that this cash comes with an obligation to your customers, a liability that must be accurately tracked until it's fulfilled.
Getting your gift card accounting right from the moment of sale is crucial for maintaining accurate financial records. While it feels like a win when a customer buys a gift card, that cash isn't technically revenue yet. Instead, accounting principles require you to treat it as a liability—a promise to deliver a product or service later. This approach ensures your financial statements, like the income statement and balance sheet, reflect the true state of your business.
The process involves a few key steps, from creating the initial journal entry to eventually recognizing the revenue when the card is used. It’s all governed by the official revenue recognition standard, ASC 606, which provides a clear framework for handling these transactions. Understanding this framework isn't just about compliance; it gives you a more accurate picture of your company's financial health. Let's walk through exactly how to handle the accounting so your books stay clean and audit-ready. For more deep dives into financial operations, you can find plenty of helpful articles on our HubiFi blog.
When a customer buys a gift card, your business receives cash, but you haven't earned that money yet. Think of it as an IOU. You've made a promise to provide goods or services in the future, and until you fulfill that promise, the money isn't yours to claim as revenue. In accounting terms, this is called deferred revenue, or unearned revenue.
Because you haven't earned the money, the value of the gift card is recorded as a liability on your company's balance sheet. This liability account shows exactly how much you owe to your customers in future products or services. It will stay on your books as a liability until the customer comes back to redeem their card.
To keep your books accurate, you need to make two distinct journal entries: one for the sale and one for the redemption.
First, when a gift card is sold, you increase your cash (an asset) and increase your deferred revenue (a liability). The entry looks like this:
Later, when the customer redeems the gift card to make a purchase, you can finally recognize the revenue. At this point, you decrease the liability and increase your sales revenue. The second entry is:
Manually tracking these entries can become complex, especially for high-volume businesses. Using a system with seamless integrations can automate this process, ensuring accuracy without the manual effort.
The reason we treat gift cards this way comes down to a core accounting standard: ASC 606, Revenue from Contracts with Customers. This is the main rulebook for recognizing revenue, and it treats a gift card sale as a contract between you and your customer. You have a "performance obligation" to fulfill—providing the goods or services they paid for.
Under ASC 606, you can only recognize revenue when you satisfy that obligation. Since the obligation isn't met until the card is used, the payment remains a liability. This standard also provides guidance on what to do with unused gift card funds, a concept known as breakage in accounting, which we'll cover next.
So, you’ve sold a gift card. The cash is in your account, which feels like a win. But from an accounting perspective, that money isn't truly yours to count as revenue just yet. The key to getting gift card accounting right is understanding the timing. Recognizing revenue isn't about when you receive the cash; it's about when you fulfill your promise to the customer. Let's break down exactly when that moment happens and why it matters so much for the health of your business.
The simple rule is this: you can only recognize revenue from a gift card when a customer actually uses it to buy something. When someone first purchases the card, you haven't provided any goods or services. You've only accepted payment for a future obligation. That initial payment is recorded as a liability on your balance sheet, often called "deferred revenue" or "unearned revenue." It represents the promise you've made to the cardholder. Only when they redeem the card for a product or service have you truly earned the income, allowing you to move the amount from the liability account to the revenue account on your income statement.
Getting the timing wrong can seriously distort your financial picture. If you record gift card sales as immediate income, you're making your company look more profitable than it actually is. This inflated view can lead to poor strategic decisions, like overspending on inventory or marketing based on revenue you haven't technically earned. This practice also creates major headaches during audits and can damage trust with investors who rely on accurate financials. Until a customer redeems their card, that sale sits on your balance sheet as a liability. Proper data integration ensures these transactions are tracked correctly across all your systems, giving you a clear and accurate view of your financial standing.
Following the correct accounting rules isn't just good practice—it's essential for staying compliant and avoiding financial penalties. The primary standard governing this process is the Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 606. This rulebook provides a clear framework for recognizing revenue from contracts with customers, which includes gift cards. Adhering to ASC 606 ensures your financial statements are accurate, consistent, and comparable. It also provides specific guidance on more complex scenarios, like how to account for unused gift card balances, known as breakage. Sticking to these standards helps you avoid tax issues, pass audits smoothly, and maintain a financially sound business.
It’s a familiar story: a customer buys a gift card, but it ends up forgotten in a wallet or a desk drawer. While it might seem like free money for your business, you can't just pocket the cash. The value from sold but unredeemed gift cards is called "breakage," and accounting for it requires a specific approach to stay compliant and keep your financial statements accurate. Recognizing this revenue isn't a guessing game; it's a calculated process based on customer behavior and accounting principles. Let's walk through how to handle it correctly.
Breakage is the portion of gift card revenue that a business never expects to redeem. Think of it as the value of all those gift cards that are sold but ultimately go unused by customers. While it eventually becomes income, you can't recognize it immediately. Instead, you have to follow specific rules to determine when and how to move that money from a liability to revenue on your books. Understanding what breakage is in accounting is the first step toward managing this unique stream of income and ensuring your financial reporting is both accurate and compliant with standards like ASC 606.
To recognize breakage, you first need a reliable way to estimate it. The best method is to look at your own historical data. By analyzing how many gift cards have been redeemed over the past five to ten years, you can establish a solid, data-backed breakage rate for your business. If your company is new and lacks historical data, a common starting point is to assume a breakage rate between 5% and 10%. The key is that this isn't a one-time calculation. You should regularly review your redemption patterns and update your breakage estimates to ensure they remain accurate as your business grows and customer habits change.
Once you have an estimated breakage rate, you can begin recognizing that revenue. Under ASC 606, the most common approach is the "proportionate method." This means you don't recognize all the expected breakage at once. Instead, you recognize it in proportion to actual gift card redemptions. For example, as customers redeem their gift cards, you would recognize a proportional amount of the estimated breakage as revenue in the same period. This method ensures that revenue is recognized in a pattern that reflects customer behavior. It’s crucial to follow these ASC 606 guidelines and consider state laws, as they dictate exactly how and when you can count breakage as income.
Just when you think you’ve got gift card accounting figured out, another layer of compliance comes into play: escheatment. This isn't just accounting jargon; it's a set of state-specific laws that dictate what happens to "unclaimed property," including the balances on long-forgotten gift cards. If you sell gift cards to customers across the country, you can't afford to ignore these rules. They directly impact whether that unredeemed cash on your books eventually becomes your revenue or gets handed over to the state government. For high-volume businesses, the potential liability from unmanaged unclaimed property can be significant, leading to audits, fines, and a messy balance sheet.
The complexity multiplies quickly. Each state has its own set of rules, dormancy periods, and reporting requirements. What’s compliant in Texas might not be in California or New York. This patchwork of legislation creates a major challenge for any business with a national customer base. Manually tracking the location for each gift card sale and monitoring dozens of different escheatment timelines is not just inefficient—it’s nearly impossible to do accurately at scale. This is where many businesses stumble, letting potential liabilities accumulate without a clear plan. Understanding escheatment is a critical piece of the revenue recognition puzzle that separates businesses with clean, audit-ready books from those facing compliance risks down the road.
At its core, escheatment is the process of turning over unclaimed financial assets to the state. Think of it as a lost-and-found for money. Some states have laws that require companies to hand over the value of unredeemed gift cards after a certain "dormancy period," which is often three to five years. The catch is that these unclaimed property laws vary wildly from one state to another. Some states may exempt gift cards entirely, while others have strict reporting and remittance requirements. This patchwork of regulations makes accounting much more complicated for businesses that operate in multiple locations, as you have to track and comply with different rules for different customers.
Escheatment laws directly influence when—or if—you can recognize revenue from unused gift cards. While ASC 606 provides guidance on recognizing breakage, state laws can essentially override that. If a gift card's balance is subject to escheatment, you can't claim it as breakage revenue. Instead, that cash remains a liability on your books until you either remit it to the state or the customer finally makes a purchase. This creates a tricky situation where you’re holding cash that isn’t truly yours to keep. It underscores the importance of knowing which state’s laws apply to each transaction, which is typically based on the customer's last known address.
Staying on top of escheatment requires a proactive approach. Your gift card accounting must follow the rules of both GAAP and the specific states where you do business. The first step is to understand the laws in every state you operate in. Next, you need a system to track gift card issuance dates, redemption activity, and customer locations to monitor dormancy periods accurately. Manually managing this is a recipe for compliance headaches and potential penalties. Automating your financial operations with the right integrations can help you track these details seamlessly, ensuring you meet your obligations without letting unclaimed property become a liability risk.
Gift card accounting isn't just about getting the numbers right; it's also about following the rules. Staying compliant protects your business from penalties and ensures you're treating customers fairly. When managing gift card revenue, there are three main areas to watch: accounting standards, sales tax, and expiration laws. Getting a handle on these rules now will save you major headaches later. Think of it as building a solid foundation for your gift card program—one that supports growth without creating risk. Let's walk through what you need to know.
When it comes to recognizing revenue, ASC 606 is the official rulebook. For gift cards, it provides clear guidance on handling unused balances, or breakage. You can't just recognize all the breakage income at once. Instead, ASC 606 generally requires you to recognize it in proportion to the rate at which customers are redeeming their gift cards. This is often called the "proportionate method." As you recognize revenue from redeemed cards, you can also recognize a proportional slice of the estimated breakage. This approach ensures your financial statements accurately reflect customer behavior.
This is a common point of confusion, but the rule is simple: you do not collect sales tax when a customer buys a gift card. Why? Because the sale of a gift card is recorded as a liability, not a final sale. Think of it like cash. The sales tax comes into play only when the customer uses the gift card to purchase a taxable item. At that point, you calculate and collect sales tax on the product, just as you would with any other transaction. Getting this wrong can lead to messy sales tax filings.
Customer protection laws play a big role in how you manage gift cards. Under federal law, a gift card cannot expire for at least five years from the date it was purchased or last reloaded. This gives your customers plenty of time to use their balance. Beyond that, you also need to be aware of state-specific "escheatment laws." These laws deal with unclaimed property—in this case, unredeemed gift card balances. After a certain period of inactivity, some states may require you to remit the remaining value to the state. These rules vary widely, so it's crucial to understand the laws where you operate.
Gift card accounting seems straightforward on the surface, but a few common slip-ups can lead to inaccurate financial statements and compliance headaches. Getting it right means understanding that a gift card sale isn't the same as a product sale. It’s a promise to deliver value later.
Many businesses stumble when it comes to timing revenue recognition, handling unused card balances, and keeping up with state-specific regulations. These aren't just minor bookkeeping errors; they can misrepresent your company's financial health and create audit risks. Let's walk through the most frequent mistakes so you can steer clear of them.
It’s tempting to count the cash from a gift card sale as revenue the moment you receive it, but that’s the number one mistake. When a customer buys a gift card, you haven't earned that money yet. Instead, you’ve created a liability on your balance sheet. Think of it as an obligation—you owe that customer goods or services in the future.
This income should be recorded as deferred revenue until the card is actually used for a purchase. Only when a customer redeems their gift card can you move the amount from the liability account to your revenue account. Recognizing it too early inflates your sales figures and gives you a misleading picture of your performance.
What happens when gift cards are never used? That leftover value is called "breakage," and it’s another area where accounting can get tricky. Many businesses either forget to account for breakage or recognize it without a clear, compliant method. While you can eventually claim this unused money as income, you can't just do it whenever you feel like it.
Properly accounting for breakage requires you to estimate how much of your gift card liability is unlikely to be redeemed based on historical data. You also need strong internal controls to track this accurately, often by using a separate contra-liability account. Without a systematic approach, you risk misstating both your liabilities and your income.
Gift card regulations aren't just set at the federal level; states have their own rules, particularly when it comes to unclaimed property. These are known as escheatment laws. Many states require businesses to hand over the value of unredeemed gift cards after a certain period, typically three to five years. This means that money doesn't automatically become your profit.
For businesses operating in multiple states, this creates a complex web of compliance duties. Ignoring these rules can lead to penalties and audits. It’s essential to understand the laws in every state you operate in and have systems in place that can handle these different requirements, which is where seamless software integrations become incredibly valuable.
Managing gift card accounting doesn't have to be a source of stress. While the rules can feel complicated, the right processes can make a world of difference. Moving away from manual spreadsheets and embracing a more systematic approach is the key to accuracy and efficiency. When you have clear systems in place, you reduce the risk of human error, save countless hours on reconciliation, and gain a much clearer picture of your company’s financial health. This isn't just about staying out of trouble with auditors; it's about having reliable numbers to make smarter business decisions.
The goal is to create a repeatable, reliable workflow that handles gift card transactions from sale to redemption without constant oversight. This involves three core steps: establishing robust tracking with automated controls, integrating your sales platforms with your accounting software, and maintaining meticulous documentation that keeps you prepared for anything. By focusing on these areas, you can build a process that not only ensures compliance but also provides valuable insights from your data. Getting this right means you can confidently report your financials and spend less time buried in administrative tasks. Let's walk through how to set up each component.
First things first: you need a solid system for tracking every gift card. This means keeping a detailed record of each card's entire lifecycle—when it was issued, its value, every time it's used, and the remaining balance. Doing this manually is a recipe for errors. Instead, using specialized software can automate this entire process for you. A good system will track sales and redemptions in real time, help you accurately calculate what breakage is, and ensure you’re following revenue recognition rules automatically. This removes the guesswork and gives you a reliable source of truth for all gift card activity.
A great tracking system becomes even more powerful when it works seamlessly with your other financial tools. Your gift card platform should connect directly with your point-of-sale (POS) system and your accounting software. This integration is crucial because it eliminates the need for manual data entry, which is often where mistakes happen. When your systems are connected, sales and redemption data flows automatically, ensuring your financial records are always up-to-date and accurate. This level of automation is what transforms gift card accounting from a tedious chore into an efficient, hands-off process that you can trust.
Finally, maintaining clean, well-organized records is non-negotiable. Think of it as preparing for an audit before one is even on the horizon. Every gift card transaction should be clearly documented so that you can easily explain and defend your accounting treatment. This starts with the fundamental rule: always record gift card sales as a liability, not as immediate revenue. Keeping clear documentation proves that you are handling these transactions correctly and following accounting standards. This practice not only makes potential audits much smoother but also reinforces good financial discipline within your business, giving you and your stakeholders confidence in your numbers.
Getting gift card accounting right comes down to having a solid system. By putting a few key practices in place, you can keep your financial reporting clean, compliant, and audit-ready. It’s all about creating a process that is consistent, transparent, and simple for your team to follow. Let's walk through the three most important habits to build.
Think of internal controls as the rulebook for your gift card program. Your goal is to set up clear guidelines for how gift cards are managed from start to finish. This means defining who has the authority to issue cards, process redemptions, and handle adjustments. Having strong internal controls helps prevent both honest mistakes and potential fraud, protecting your assets and ensuring your data is reliable. Document these procedures and make sure your team is trained on them. When everyone knows the right way to handle a transaction, you reduce the risk of errors that could throw off your books.
Your gift card liability account deserves the same attention as your bank account. On a consistent basis—at least monthly—you need to reconcile it. This involves comparing the liability balance on your general ledger with the detailed report from your sales system showing all outstanding gift card values. Do the numbers match? If not, it's time to investigate. Regular monitoring helps you catch discrepancies early, before they snowball into a major headache during an audit. This simple habit is fundamental to keeping your records accurate and maintaining confidence in your financial statements.
Manually tracking every gift card sale, redemption, and breakage calculation is a recipe for errors, especially as your business grows. This is where technology becomes your best friend. Using an automated revenue recognition platform can handle the heavy lifting for you. The right software tracks sales and redemptions in real time, applies your breakage policy consistently, and generates the journal entries you need for ASC 606 compliance. Automation saves countless hours and greatly improves the accuracy of your financial data, turning a complex process into a streamlined operation.
Why can't I count a gift card sale as revenue immediately? Think of a gift card sale as a promise, not a completed transaction. When a customer buys a gift card, you've received their cash, but you haven't given them a product or service in return yet. Accounting rules require you to wait until you've fulfilled your end of the deal. Until the card is used, that money sits on your books as a liability—an obligation you owe to your customer. Recognizing it as revenue only happens when they redeem the card and you deliver the goods.
What happens to the money from gift cards that are never used? That leftover money from unredeemed gift cards is called "breakage." While you can eventually recognize this as income, you can't just claim it whenever you want. Proper accounting requires you to estimate a breakage rate based on your company's historical data. You then recognize this income proportionally as other customers redeem their cards. This ensures your financial reports reflect actual customer behavior rather than just a guess.
How do state laws affect my gift card accounting? State laws, known as escheatment or unclaimed property laws, can have a major impact on your books. These rules dictate that after a certain period of inactivity (often three to five years), the value of an unredeemed gift card may belong to the state, not your business. If a gift card is subject to these laws, you can't recognize its value as breakage income. Instead, you may be required to turn the funds over to the state, making compliance a critical part of your accounting process.
When do I charge sales tax on a gift card purchase? This is a common point of confusion, but the rule is straightforward. You do not collect sales tax when a customer buys a gift card. The transaction is simply an exchange of one form of payment for another. The time to apply sales tax is when the customer uses the gift card to purchase a taxable item. At that point, you treat the transaction like any other sale and calculate the tax on the products or services being sold.
What's the most effective way to manage all these rules without getting overwhelmed? Trying to track every gift card's lifecycle, breakage estimate, and state compliance rule in a spreadsheet is a recipe for mistakes. The most effective approach is to use an automated system. The right software can integrate with your sales and accounting platforms to track everything in real time, apply the correct accounting rules automatically, and keep your records clean and audit-ready. This frees you from the manual work and gives you confidence in your financial data.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Meet with an expert in revenue recognition and order-to-cash accounting and automate revenue close.
*Or watch 2 minute demo here.
Power your high-volume business's revenue compliance and reporting needs with one platform.
