Sign in
Get a Demo
Talk with an accountant.
Get clear, actionable steps for gift card breakage accounting, from revenue recognition to compliance, with tips for accurate financial reporting.
Your gift card program generates more than just sales; it generates valuable data. Every purchase and redemption tells a story about customer behavior, and that story is the key to accurate financial reporting. When a portion of those gift cards inevitably goes unused, you can't just guess how much to recognize as income. You need a data-driven estimate to justify your numbers and satisfy auditors. This is the foundation of modern gift card breakage accounting. It’s about using your own historical patterns to create a reliable model for recognizing revenue, ensuring your financial statements reflect reality and stand up to scrutiny.
When you sell a gift card, you’re not just making a sale; you’re creating a liability. You owe the customer goods or services worth the card's value. But what happens when that gift card gets lost in a wallet or forgotten in a drawer? That unredeemed balance is known as breakage, and how you account for it has a real impact on your financial reporting and overall profitability. Understanding the fundamentals of breakage is the first step toward managing it correctly and staying compliant.
Let's start with a simple definition. Gift card breakage is the portion of a gift card's value that a customer never redeems. Instead of remaining a liability on your books forever, accounting principles allow you to eventually recognize this unclaimed value as revenue. Think of it as a sale that was promised but never fully completed. Understanding the full impact of gift card breakage is essential because it directly affects how you report both your liabilities and your revenue, giving you a more accurate picture of your company’s financial health.
At first glance, breakage might seem like pure profit, but it's a bit more complex. While it’s true that recognizing breakage can contribute positively to your revenue, the primary goal is accurate financial reporting. Proper gift card accounting ensures your financial statements reflect the true state of your liabilities. Getting this right is critical for maintaining investor confidence, passing audits, and making informed business decisions. When you implement sound gift card accounting practices, you build a more resilient and trustworthy business from the ground up.
This is where accounting standards come into play. Under ASC 606, the rules for revenue recognition have become more specific. You can no longer just wait a few years and then claim all unredeemed balances as income. Instead, companies are expected to estimate the amount of breakage they anticipate and recognize it proportionally as customers redeem their gift cards. This approach aligns revenue recognition with actual customer behavior, making your financial statements more reliable. These new accounting rules provide a clearer, more consistent framework for handling the revenue from unredeemed gift cards.
The introduction of ASC 606 marked a significant shift in how businesses approach revenue recognition, and gift card accounting was right in the middle of it. Before this standard, the rules for handling breakage were less uniform, often leading companies to wait until a gift card expired or redemption seemed highly unlikely before recognizing any revenue. ASC 606 introduced a more principle-based model, providing clearer guidance that often allows businesses to recognize this revenue sooner. The new framework focuses on aligning revenue recognition with the fulfillment of performance obligations to customers, which changes the timing and calculation of breakage income.
The biggest change under ASC 606 is the timing. The new standard allows companies to recognize breakage revenue in proportion to the pattern of gift card redemptions. Think of it this way: instead of waiting for years, you can now recognize a portion of the expected breakage every time a customer uses a gift card. This approach better reflects the economic reality of the transaction. It requires a reliable estimate of the total breakage you expect, based on your company’s historical data. This shift means your financial statements can show a more current and accurate picture of your revenue streams, but it also means you need a solid system for tracking redemption patterns and updating your estimates.
When you sell a gift card, you receive cash, but you haven't actually made a sale yet. From an accounting perspective, you've created a "performance obligation." This is simply a promise to provide goods or services to the customer in the future. The money you collected is recorded as a liability on your balance sheet, often called "unearned revenue" or "deferred revenue." This liability stays on your books until the customer redeems the card. Only then have you fulfilled your promise, allowing you to move that amount from the liability column to the revenue column on your income statement. This concept is central to modern revenue recognition and is the foundation for how you account for both redemptions and breakage.
Under ASC 606, you can recognize breakage revenue when the likelihood of the customer redeeming the remaining value is remote. The standard allows you to do this proportionally as other customers redeem their cards. To do this, you first need to estimate the total amount of breakage you expect. This estimate should be based on your historical redemption data. For example, if your data shows that about 10% of gift card values are never redeemed, you can recognize 10% of each redemption as breakage revenue. If you’re a new business without much history, you can start with industry benchmarks and refine your estimate over time. Having the right data integrations is key to tracking this accurately and keeping your financial reporting compliant.
Estimating gift card breakage isn't about pulling a number out of thin air. It’s a calculated process that helps you accurately reflect your company’s financial health while staying compliant with accounting standards like ASC 606. Think of it as making an educated prediction based on solid evidence. The goal is to determine the portion of your gift card liability that you can reasonably expect will never be redeemed. Getting this estimate right is crucial for accurate financial reporting. Most businesses use a combination of a few key methods to land on a reliable breakage rate, starting with their own history and branching out from there. Let's walk through the three most common approaches.
Your own past performance is the best crystal ball you have. If your business has been selling gift cards for a few years, you have a treasure trove of data waiting to be analyzed. Start by looking at the redemption patterns for gift cards sold in previous periods. What percentage of cards from two or three years ago were actually used? This historical redemption rate is your strongest starting point for estimating future breakage. For new businesses without years of data, you can begin with a conservative estimate—many start in the 5-10% range—and then refine that number as you accumulate your own data over time.
What if you’re a new company or don't have enough historical data to create a reliable estimate? In that case, you can look to industry benchmarks. This involves researching the average breakage rates for businesses similar to yours in size and sector. For example, a new restaurant could look at data from other fast-casual or fine-dining establishments to get a reasonable starting point. You can often find this information in industry reports or financial publications. While benchmarks are a helpful guide, remember that they are just an average. Your specific customer behavior might be different, so it’s best to use this method as a temporary solution while you gather your own data.
For the most accurate prediction, you can apply statistical models. This approach goes beyond simple historical averages and uses more sophisticated analysis to forecast redemption patterns. It requires a system that can collect and process detailed information about gift card sales and usage over time. By analyzing this data, you can identify trends and create a model that more precisely predicts how much of your outstanding gift card balance will go unredeemed. This method allows you to recognize breakage income with greater confidence and often sooner. Setting up the right data integrations is key to making this approach work, as it ensures all your sales and redemption data flows into one place for analysis.
So, when can you actually count that money as yours? You have this pool of unredeemed gift card funds sitting on your books as a liability, and you're wondering when you can finally move it to the revenue column. Under ASC 606, you can't just make the switch whenever you feel like it. The rules require you to recognize breakage revenue in proportion to the pattern of rights exercised by the customer. In simpler terms, you need a solid, data-backed reason to believe the customer isn't coming back to redeem their card.
This isn't about guesswork; it's about justification. Getting this wrong can lead to compliance headaches and inaccurate financial statements, while getting it right provides a clearer picture of your company's performance. To do it right, you need to clear a few key hurdles. First, you have to be confident that the likelihood of redemption is very low. Second, this confidence must come from analyzing your customers' actual behavior and historical redemption patterns. And finally, you need a system in place to track all of this meticulously. Let's walk through what each of these steps looks like in practice.
Before you can recognize a single dollar of breakage, you need to establish that there's a high probability the gift card will go unredeemed. Think of it as a confidence test. You can't simply decide that after six months, you'll count the money as yours. You need a reliable method for estimating when that redemption becomes unlikely. This threshold is your green light for recognizing breakage revenue. It’s the point where you can confidently say, based on solid evidence, that the customer is not likely to use the remaining balance. Without meeting this probability standard, any unredeemed funds must remain on your books as a liability.
So, how do you prove that high probability? By looking at your own history. Your company’s unique historical redemption pattern is the most important piece of evidence. For example, Best Buy determined that after 24 months, the likelihood of a gift card being used was remote, so they began recognizing breakage at that point. Your timeline might be 18 months, or it could be 36. The only way to know is to analyze your data. Look at when cards are purchased versus when they are redeemed. Over time, you'll see a clear trend showing when redemptions drop off significantly. This pattern becomes the foundation for your breakage recognition policy.
Having a great estimation model means nothing if your records are a mess. Proper gift card accounting goes far beyond just booking the initial sale. It requires a system for carefully tracking liabilities, redemptions, and, of course, breakage. Manually managing this across spreadsheets is not only time-consuming but also incredibly risky, especially as your business grows. Automated solutions are designed to handle this complexity, streamlining everything from tracking sales to calculating breakage revenue. Having the right integrations with your accounting software ensures your data is accurate, your financials are closed on time, and you’re always ready for an audit.
Handling unredeemed gift cards isn't just an accounting puzzle—it's a legal one, too. Before you can recognize breakage as revenue, you need to understand the rules that govern abandoned property and consumer rights. These regulations vary significantly from state to state and can have a major impact on your financial reporting. Getting this wrong can lead to audits, fines, and other penalties, so it’s crucial to get your facts straight.
The two main areas you need to pay attention to are escheatment laws and consumer protection rules. Escheatment deals with what happens to unclaimed funds, while consumer protection laws set standards for things like expiration dates. Both directly influence when—or if—you can claim unredeemed gift card balances as income. Having a system that can track gift card data alongside these complex legal requirements is essential for staying compliant. With the right integrations, you can connect your sales and accounting platforms to ensure your data is always accurate and ready for reporting.
"Escheatment" is a legal term for the process of turning over unclaimed property to the state. In the context of gift cards, some states consider unredeemed balances to be unclaimed property after a certain period, often three to five years. These laws require companies to remit the value of these dormant gift cards to the state government.
If your business operates in a state with these laws, you cannot simply count the unredeemed balance as breakage income. You are legally obligated to hand that money over. This is a critical distinction because it means that a significant portion of what might look like potential revenue on your books actually belongs to the state. It's vital to research the specific laws in every state where you do business.
Beyond escheatment, you also have to follow federal and state consumer protection laws. The federal Credit CARD Act of 2009, for instance, mandates that gift cards cannot expire for at least five years from the date they were purchased. Many states have their own additional rules that offer even more protection.
These regulations directly affect how you account for breakage. If a gift card has an expiration date, you can generally recognize the remaining balance as breakage income when it expires. However, this is only after you’ve accounted for any money that must be turned over to the state under escheatment laws. Think of it as a two-step process: first, satisfy your legal obligation to the state, then you can recognize any remaining, permissible amount as revenue.
Staying on the right side of the law requires careful and consistent effort. Accurate accounting for gift card breakage is essential for ensuring your financial statements are correct and that you’re meeting all revenue recognition standards.
Here’s a simple checklist to help you stay compliant:
Gift card breakage isn't just an operational detail—it has a direct and noticeable effect on your company's core financial statements. Understanding how it moves through your balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement is key to painting an accurate picture of your financial health. When you get it right, you ensure compliance and gain clearer insight into your business's performance. Let's walk through how breakage appears on each of these critical reports.
When a customer buys a gift card, your cash goes up, but your sales revenue doesn't—at least not yet. Instead, you record that amount as a liability on your balance sheet, often called "unearned revenue" or "deferred revenue." Think of it as a promise you've made to provide goods or services later. This liability stays on your books, reflecting what you owe to your gift card holders. As customers redeem their cards, the liability decreases. Correctly managing this liability is crucial for presenting an accurate snapshot of your company's financial position at any given time.
Your income statement gets its moment when revenue is actually earned. When a gift card is used for a purchase, you can finally move that amount from the liability column on your balance sheet to the revenue line on your income statement. The same goes for breakage. Based on your company’s historical redemption patterns, you can estimate the portion of gift cards that will likely go unused. Once you meet the criteria under accounting standards like ASC 606, you can recognize this estimated breakage as revenue. This directly increases your reported income, which is why getting your breakage estimates right is so important for accurate financial reporting.
From a cash flow perspective, gift cards are great for business. You receive cash immediately when a customer purchases a card, giving you an upfront improvement in liquidity. This transaction shows up as a positive inflow in the operating activities section of your cash flow statement. The best part? The cash from breakage is money you get to keep without ever having to exchange it for products or services. This unredeemed value can significantly improve your short-term cash position. Properly accounting for it ensures your financial statements accurately reflect this benefit, giving you a clearer view of your company's liquidity and overall financial health.
While the concept of breakage seems straightforward, putting it into practice can bring up some tricky situations. Getting breakage accounting right means staying on top of several moving parts, from shifting regulations to complex data management. It’s not just about tracking sales; it’s about creating a complete financial picture that stands up to scrutiny. Many businesses find that what seems simple on the surface requires a robust system to manage correctly.
Let's walk through some of the most common hurdles you might face and how to think about them. Understanding these challenges is the first step to building a process that is both compliant and accurate, ensuring your financial statements reflect the true performance of your gift card program.
Gift card accounting involves more than just recording sales. It requires careful tracking of liabilities, revenue recognition upon redemption, and management of breakage income. If your sales data from your point-of-sale system doesn't communicate with your accounting software, you're left with a manual reconciliation nightmare. This disconnect can lead to errors, wasted time, and an inaccurate view of your liabilities. A solid system requires seamless data integrations to ensure that every transaction, from purchase to redemption, is automatically and accurately accounted for. Without this, you're always playing catch-up instead of having a real-time view of your financials.
Accurately estimating and recognizing breakage revenue is essential for sound financial planning. This isn't a wild guess; it's a calculated forecast based on your company's specific data. You'll need to analyze historical redemption patterns and customer behavior to develop a reliable estimate. For newer businesses without years of data, this can be particularly challenging. The key is to establish a clear, defensible methodology from the start and refine it as you gather more information. Your goal is to create an estimation model that you can consistently apply and justify during an audit, proving that your numbers are based on logic, not luck.
The rules surrounding unredeemed gift cards aren't the same everywhere. Some states have escheatment laws that require businesses to hand over the value of old, unused gift cards to the state after a certain period. These "unclaimed property" laws can turn what you thought was breakage revenue into a liability you owe the government. It's crucial to know your state's rules and stay on top of any changes, as they can vary significantly. Ignoring these regulations can lead to significant fines and legal headaches, so building compliance directly into your accounting process is non-negotiable.
One of the biggest questions in breakage accounting is when you can actually book the revenue. Under ASC 606, you can only recognize breakage as income when there's a high probability that the card won't be redeemed. This means you can't just recognize it after a year has passed. You need a reliable method for determining when that "remote likelihood of redemption" has been met. Recognizing revenue too early can misstate your income and lead to compliance issues, while waiting too long can understate your performance. This makes having a clear, data-backed policy for the timing of revenue recognition absolutely critical.
Gift card accounting can feel like a maze of rules and regulations, and a few common misconceptions can easily lead you astray. Getting it wrong doesn't just mess up your books; it can land you in hot water with auditors and state regulators. Let's clear the air and bust three of the most persistent myths about gift card breakage so you can handle your revenue recognition with confidence.
It’s tempting to see a gift card sale as instant revenue, but that’s not how it works. When you sell a gift card, you’re creating a liability—a promise to provide goods or services later. You can’t recognize that cash as income right away. Breakage revenue can only be recognized when you have strong evidence that the card is unlikely to be redeemed. According to revenue recognition rules, you need a reliable method for estimating breakage based on historical data. This ensures your financial statements accurately reflect your obligations and is a key part of maintaining ASC 606 compliance. Rushing to recognize revenue too soon overstates your income and misrepresents your financial health.
Seeing a large unredeemed balance on your books doesn't mean you can claim it all as breakage income. The total unredeemed amount is just a starting point. True breakage is the portion of that balance you can confidently estimate will never be used. The rest remains a liability until it's either redeemed or falls under state laws. Think of it this way: "unredeemed balance" is the whole pool of outstanding gift card value, while "breakage" is the small, carefully calculated slice of that pool you can recognize as revenue. This distinction is critical for accurate accounting and prevents you from claiming income you haven't truly earned.
This is perhaps the most dangerous myth of all. Many states have unclaimed property laws, often called escheatment laws, that dictate what happens to unredeemed gift card balances. After a certain period of inactivity, some states require you to hand over the remaining value of the gift card to them. If a state claims those funds, you cannot recognize that amount as breakage income—it’s no longer your money to claim. These laws vary widely from one state to another, creating a complex compliance landscape for any business that sells gift cards. Ignoring them can lead to significant fines and penalties, making it essential to stay informed and compliant.
Getting a handle on gift card liability might seem complicated, but it boils down to creating a clear, repeatable process. A solid system not only keeps your books accurate but also gives you a much clearer picture of your company’s financial health. Think of it as a three-step loop: record the initial sale correctly, adjust your books as cards are used (or not used), and use the right tools to make it all happen smoothly. This approach turns a potential accounting headache into a manageable part of your financial operations, ensuring you stay compliant and make smarter decisions.
When a customer buys a gift card, it’s tempting to see that cash as immediate revenue. But from an accounting perspective, you haven’t earned it yet—you still owe a product or service. That's why you don't count that money as earned income right away. Instead, it's recorded as a liability on your balance sheet, often called "deferred revenue." This initial entry is critical because it accurately reflects your obligation to customers. Getting this first step right sets the foundation for proper revenue recognition and prevents you from overstating your income.
Your gift card liability isn't a "set it and forget it" number. You need to adjust it regularly as customers redeem their cards or as it becomes clear some cards will never be used. This is where breakage comes in. You can only recognize breakage as income when there's a high probability a card won't be redeemed, and you have a reliable way to estimate this. Following the ASC 606 standard, this breakage income is reported as part of your sales revenue, requiring you to constantly analyze redemption patterns to keep your financials accurate.
Manually tracking every gift card sale, redemption, and expiration date is a recipe for errors and wasted time as your business grows. This is where technology becomes your best friend. Automated solutions can streamline everything from tracking sales and redemptions to calculating breakage revenue and ensuring compliance. Implementing a system that connects your sales data with your accounting software removes the guesswork and manual data entry. This saves countless hours and provides a reliable, audit-proof record of your gift card liability, freeing you up for more strategic work.
Getting breakage reporting right comes down to having good habits and the right systems in place. It’s not about finding a magic formula but about creating a consistent process that keeps your financial data clean, compliant, and useful. Think of these practices as the foundation for turning a complex accounting task into a streamlined part of your operations. By focusing on regular updates, solid tracking, and smart integrations, you can handle breakage with confidence and make sure your financial statements accurately reflect your business's health.
Your breakage estimate isn't something you can set and forget. Customer behavior changes, redemption patterns shift, and your historical data grows over time. That's why you need to revisit your breakage calculations regularly—at least annually, but quarterly is even better. Consistently updating your estimates ensures your financial statements are as accurate as possible and reflect the latest trends in your gift card program. This practice is essential for maintaining compliance with revenue recognition standards and providing a true picture of your company's financial position. Correctly estimating and recording gift card breakage impacts everything from your revenue figures to your liabilities.
Manually tracking gift card sales, redemptions, and balances in a spreadsheet is a recipe for errors, especially as your business grows. A reliable system is non-negotiable. You need a solution that can manage your gift card data accurately and in real time. This system should track every card's lifecycle, from initial sale to full redemption or expiration. Ideally, it works seamlessly with your point-of-sale (POS) and accounting software to create a single source of truth. Automated solutions can streamline the entire process, from tracking sales and redemptions to calculating breakage revenue, making your life much easier and your data more dependable.
Gift card breakage isn't just an accounting puzzle; it's also a legal one. Many states have escheatment or unclaimed property laws that dictate what you must do with unredeemed gift card balances. Some states require you to turn over the remaining funds after a certain period of dormancy. These rules vary significantly from one state to another, and failing to comply can lead to penalties. It's crucial to understand and follow the specific escheatment laws for every state you operate in. Staying on top of these regulations protects your business and ensures you only recognize the breakage revenue you're legally entitled to keep.
A standalone gift card tracking system creates extra work and increases the risk of data entry errors. The real power comes from integrating it directly with your accounting software. When your systems talk to each other, the data flows automatically, ensuring your financial records are always up-to-date. This automation is key to accurately tracking sales, redemptions, and breakage while ensuring compliance with standards like ASC 606. With the right integrations, you can close your books faster, pass audits with less stress, and gain a clearer view of your revenue streams without the manual reconciliation headaches.
Is gift card breakage just free money for my business? Not exactly. While it does become revenue, it isn't a simple windfall you can claim whenever you want. Breakage is earned income that must be recognized according to specific accounting rules, like ASC 606. You have to prove through data that a card is unlikely to be redeemed, and you also have to account for state laws that might require you to turn over those funds. Think of it less as free money and more as the final step in an accounting process that ensures your financial reports are accurate.
What if my business is new and I don't have historical data to estimate breakage? This is a really common situation, so don't worry. When you don't have your own redemption patterns to analyze, the best place to start is with industry benchmarks. You can research the average breakage rates for businesses similar to yours in size and sector to establish a reasonable, conservative starting point. Use this as a temporary measure while you begin collecting your own data, and make a plan to review and refine your estimate as your business grows and you have more history to draw from.
Do I really have to give unredeemed gift card money to the state? In some cases, yes. Many states have unclaimed property laws, also known as escheatment laws, that treat unredeemed gift card balances as abandoned property after a certain period of inactivity. If your business operates in one of these states, you are legally required to remit those funds to the state government. This is a critical step because that money is not yours to claim as breakage revenue. It's essential to check the specific rules for every state where you sell gift cards.
What's the single biggest change ASC 606 made to handling gift card breakage? The biggest change was the timing of when you can recognize the revenue. Before ASC 606, many companies would wait until a gift card expired or a long time had passed. The new standard allows you to recognize expected breakage revenue proportionally as other customers redeem their cards. This means you can recognize it sooner, but it requires you to have a reliable, data-backed estimate of your total breakage from the start. It aligns your revenue recognition more closely with actual customer behavior.
Can I just use a spreadsheet to track my gift cards? You could, but it becomes risky and inefficient very quickly. As your business grows, manually tracking every sale, redemption, and balance across spreadsheets is prone to human error and makes it incredibly difficult to get the accurate data needed for breakage estimates. An automated system that integrates with your sales and accounting software removes the manual work, ensures your liability is always up-to-date, and provides a clear, audit-ready trail for all your gift card activity.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Meet with an expert in revenue recognition and order-to-cash accounting and automate revenue close.
*Or watch 2 minute demo here.
Power your high-volume business's revenue compliance and reporting needs with one platform.
