Sign in
Get a Demo
Talk with an accountant.
Streamline your dispute management workflow with this clear 6-step process. Save time, reduce errors, and resolve customer issues with confidence.
Many businesses treat disputes as a purely reactive task, something to deal with only after a customer complains. This approach misses a huge opportunity. Every disagreement contains valuable data about potential weaknesses in your products, services, or billing processes. By implementing a formal dispute management workflow, you create a system for not only resolving current issues but also for capturing the insights needed to prevent future ones. It transforms dispute resolution from a simple cost center into a strategic tool for continuous improvement, helping you build a more resilient operation and a more loyal customer base from the ground up.
At its core, dispute management is your company’s process for handling and resolving disagreements with customers. Think of it as a structured way to address everything from billing errors to service complaints. While it might sound like a purely reactive task, a strong dispute management process is fundamental to your financial health and operational stability. When you handle disagreements well, you keep cash flowing and customers happy.
Ignoring disputes or handling them haphazardly creates bottlenecks that can ripple through your entire business. It’s not just about fixing a single problem; it’s about maintaining a healthy financial ecosystem where payments are timely, records are accurate, and customer relationships are protected. A streamlined approach ensures that small issues don’t escalate into major financial headaches or damage your reputation. This is where having clear, integrated data becomes a game-changer, allowing you to see the full picture and resolve issues quickly.
When disputes aren't managed effectively, they do more than just create awkward conversations. They can directly slow down payments, frustrate your customers, and drain your team's time and resources. Every hour spent tracking down an invoice or clarifying a charge is an hour not spent on growing the business. The financial impact is often larger than you might think. In fact, some research suggests that businesses could be losing out on as much as 10% of their potential income due to invalid deductions and unresolved claims. These aren't just minor accounting errors; they represent real, recoverable revenue that gets lost in the shuffle.
A well-oiled dispute management process does more than just plug revenue leaks—it builds trust. When you resolve issues quickly and fairly, you show customers that you value their business. This not only helps you get paid on time but also improves your overall cash flow and financial clarity. On the flip side, delays and poor communication can make customers feel ignored and frustrated. These negative experiences are a key reason why customers leave for competitors. By investing in a solid dispute resolution workflow, you’re making a direct investment in customer retention and protecting your long-term revenue streams.
No matter how great your product or service is, disagreements are a natural part of doing business. The goal isn't to avoid disputes entirely—that's impossible—but to anticipate them so you can build a process that resolves them quickly and professionally. When you know what to look for, you can stop small misunderstandings from turning into major problems that damage customer relationships and your bottom line. Let's walk through the four most common types of disputes you're likely to see.
Disputes over money are incredibly common and often stem from simple human error. A customer might see an incorrect price on an invoice, receive the wrong quantity of goods, or disagree about payment due dates. According to research from Kolleno, these small discrepancies are frequent sources of conflict. Think about a client who was accidentally billed for the wrong subscription tier or a discount that wasn't applied correctly. These issues create friction and can make your business seem disorganized. Using an automated system for revenue recognition helps ensure your billing is accurate and consistent, reducing the manual errors that lead to these frustrating back-and-forth conversations.
"Did I really get what I paid for?" This question is at the heart of most service delivery conflicts. These disputes happen when a customer feels the quality of a service didn't meet their expectations or when they believe they were billed for something they never received. This is especially common in businesses where the "product" isn't a physical item, like consulting or software-as-a-service. A project might take longer than promised, or the final result might not align with what the client envisioned. The best way to prevent these issues is by setting crystal-clear expectations from the start with a detailed scope of work and maintaining open communication throughout the project to manage expectations.
Your contract is supposed to be your source of truth, but it can easily become a source of conflict. Disagreements often pop up when one party believes the other hasn't met the agreed-upon terms of service or delivery. This can happen if the language in the contract is vague or if verbal agreements weren't properly documented. Scope creep is another classic example—the project slowly expands beyond the original agreement, but the contract is never updated to reflect the new work. Having integrated systems that connect your project management tools to your financial records can help you track deliverables against contract terms, giving you a clear record of what's been completed.
When a customer receives a product that is defective, damaged, or simply doesn't work as advertised, you can expect a dispute. These quality issues are a direct hit to your brand's reputation and can lead to costly returns, chargebacks, and negative reviews. While a single faulty product might be a fluke, a pattern of quality complaints could point to a much larger problem with a supplier or your production process. Tracking these disputes isn't just about resolving them one by one; it's about collecting data to spot trends. Analyzing this information can help you find the root cause and prevent future issues, which you can read more about on our HubiFi blog.
Handling customer disputes can feel chaotic, especially when you’re juggling them on top of everything else. Without a plan, it’s easy for issues to get lost, resolutions to be inconsistent, and both your team and your customers to end up frustrated. A structured dispute management workflow brings order to that chaos. It’s a repeatable process that ensures every issue is handled efficiently and fairly, from the moment it’s raised to its final resolution.
Following a clear set of steps saves a massive amount of time and mental energy. Instead of reinventing the wheel for every complaint, your team knows exactly what to do. This consistency not only leads to faster resolutions but also protects your customer relationships and your bottom line. Think of it as a roadmap for turning a negative customer experience into a positive one. Here’s a simple, six-step process you can adapt for your business to manage disputes with confidence.
The moment a customer raises an issue—whether it’s through an email, a support ticket, or a phone call—the clock starts ticking. Your first move is to officially identify and log the dispute in a centralized system. This could be a simple spreadsheet, a project management tool, or a ticket in your CRM. The key is to get it out of individual inboxes and into a shared space where it can be tracked. Your log should capture the essentials: the customer’s name, contact information, the date the dispute was raised, the relevant invoice or order number, and a clear summary of the problem. This creates a single source of truth and ensures nothing gets forgotten.
Not all disputes carry the same weight. A minor billing question is very different from a major service failure affecting a key account. That’s why the next step is to categorize and prioritize each issue. Sorting disputes into types like "Billing Error," "Product Quality," or "Shipping Delay" helps you spot patterns later on. Then, assess the urgency. You can prioritize based on factors like the monetary value involved, the customer’s history, or the potential impact on your business. This allows you to direct your resources effectively, assigning your most experienced team members to the most critical cases while ensuring smaller issues are still handled promptly.
Before you can solve a problem, you need to understand it completely. This step is all about objective fact-finding. Gather all the relevant documentation connected to the dispute, such as contracts, purchase orders, invoices, and any email correspondence. The goal is to build a clear timeline and understand exactly what happened from both your perspective and the customer’s. A thorough investigation helps you identify the root cause, not just the surface-level complaint. Having well-organized data and seamless integrations between your systems makes this process much faster, as all the information you need is readily accessible.
Resolving a dispute is often a team effort. It’s rare that one person has all the answers, so your next step is to communicate with key internal stakeholders. You might need to talk to the sales team to clarify what was promised in the initial agreement, check with the warehouse about shipping details, or consult with your finance department on billing specifics. Bringing the right people into the conversation ensures that the solution you propose is accurate, fair, and something your business can actually deliver on. This collaborative approach also helps create alignment across departments and prevents similar issues from happening again.
Once your investigation is complete and you’ve decided on a course of action, it’s time to implement the resolution. This could mean issuing a credit memo, processing a refund, sending a replacement product, or simply providing the customer with a detailed explanation that clears up a misunderstanding. How you communicate the solution is just as important as the solution itself. Reach out to the customer with empathy, clearly explain the steps you’re taking, and apologize for the inconvenience. Your goal is not just to close a ticket but to restore the customer’s trust and show them you value their business.
After you’ve resolved the issue with the customer, there’s one final step: documenting everything and officially closing the case. Update your dispute log with a summary of the resolution, the actions taken, and the date the case was closed. This detailed record is incredibly valuable. It serves as a reference if the customer has future questions and provides crucial data for your financial records. Over time, you can analyze this data to identify recurring problems, which you can find more information about on the HubiFi Blog. This turns every dispute into a learning opportunity to improve your products, services, and processes.
Let’s be honest: managing disputes manually is a time-consuming process that’s prone to human error. It often involves digging through spreadsheets, forwarding endless email chains, and trying to piece together information from different departments. This is where automation comes in. By introducing automated workflows, you can handle disputes faster, more accurately, and with far less manual effort.
Think of automation as giving your team a smart assistant. It takes care of the repetitive, administrative tasks, freeing up your people to focus on what they do best: solving complex problems and taking care of your customers. An automated system creates a clear, consistent process that ensures nothing gets missed. It provides a central place for all dispute-related information, giving you the visibility needed to spot recurring issues and improve your operations from the ground up. This shift not only makes your internal process more efficient but also leads to quicker resolutions and happier customers.
One of the biggest challenges in dispute management is simply getting the right information to the right person quickly. Automation solves this by instantly identifying and capturing disputes from various channels, like your payment processor or customer service inbox. Once a dispute is logged, the system can automatically categorize it based on predefined rules. For example, an issue flagged as a “billing error” is immediately routed to the finance team, while a “product defect” claim goes straight to the support or logistics department. This automated dispute management eliminates the manual triage process, reduces response times, and ensures every issue is assigned to the team best equipped to handle it.
Are you still tracking disputes in a spreadsheet? If so, you know how quickly it can become outdated and difficult to manage. Automated systems provide real-time dashboards and workflows that give everyone a clear view of where each dispute stands. Team members can see their assigned tasks, managers can monitor progress, and leadership can get a high-level overview of dispute volume and resolution times. This transparency helps identify bottlenecks before they become major problems. With everyone working from the same up-to-date information, your team can resolve issues faster and keep the entire process moving smoothly. You can find more insights in the HubiFi Blog on how to achieve this level of data clarity.
Beyond simple task routing, automation powered by artificial intelligence (AI) can uncover valuable insights from your dispute data. AI algorithms can analyze thousands of past disputes to identify recurring patterns and root causes that a person might miss. For instance, it might reveal that a specific product is consistently linked to quality complaints or that billing errors spike after a certain marketing promotion. By spotting these trends, you can address the underlying problems instead of just treating the symptoms. This proactive approach not only helps prevent future disputes but can also improve recovery rates—in some cases by as much as 30%.
For automation to be truly effective, it needs to work seamlessly with the tools you already use. A strong dispute management solution should connect directly with your existing systems, including your CRM, ERP, and accounting software. This creates a unified workflow where data flows automatically between platforms, eliminating the need for manual data entry and reducing the risk of errors. When your dispute process is integrated with your order-to-cash cycle, for example, your team has all the necessary context—like customer history and transaction details—right at their fingertips. This level of connectivity is key to building an efficient, scalable process, and you can explore what seamless integrations with HubiFi look like.
A solid workflow needs the right tools to bring it to life. The goal is to centralize information and automate repetitive tasks so your team can focus on resolving issues, not chasing down data. The right tech stack makes your entire dispute management process faster and more efficient.
Many disputes start with a question about a charge. If your revenue data is messy, answering it is a headache. This is where HubiFi becomes foundational. By automating revenue recognition, you ensure every transaction is accurately recorded and compliant with standards like ASC 606. This creates a clear audit trail. When a billing dispute arises, your team has immediate access to clean, reliable data to validate the charge and resolve the issue quickly. It’s about preventing disputes by maintaining impeccable financial hygiene.
For businesses with a high volume of claims, dedicated platforms are a game-changer. These tools are built to streamline the entire process. Some offer an end-to-end disputes management workflow that connects every step on a single system. Others help you simplify the dispute process by letting you receive, analyze, and process claims from one dashboard. These solutions automate tasks like categorizing claims and assigning them to the right team members, which cuts down on manual work.
Your dispute process shouldn't live on an island. Integrating it with your existing systems, especially your CRM, is key. When a dispute is logged, your team needs the full customer story—past communications, contracts, and order history. A dispute management solution that connects with your tech stack puts all this information at their fingertips. This eliminates jumping between applications, saving time and ensuring your team has the context to handle the dispute effectively.
Clear communication is essential for quick resolutions. Tools like Slack or Microsoft Teams are perfect for this. When a complex dispute comes in, you can create a dedicated channel and pull in the right people from finance, sales, and support. This keeps all conversations and decisions organized in one place. Instead of relying on long email chains, your team can collaborate in real-time. This kind of efficient dispute management ensures everyone is on the same page, leading to faster outcomes.
Setting up a new dispute management workflow is a huge step forward, but it’s not always a straight line from A to B. You might run into a few common bumps along the way, especially when you’re shifting away from old habits. The good news is that these challenges are completely solvable. By focusing on the right areas—like reducing manual tasks, getting teams to work together, and organizing your data—you can create a process that’s smooth, efficient, and built to last.
If your team is buried in spreadsheets and manual data entry, you’re not just losing time—you’re opening the door to human error. The goal is to streamline your workflows so your team can focus on solving problems, not just processing paperwork. Automated dispute management tools can take over the repetitive tasks, like routing claims and flagging issues, which minimizes mistakes and speeds up resolution times. This shift doesn't just make your process more efficient; it frees up your team to handle more strategic work that actually impacts the business.
Disputes rarely live in one department. A billing issue might start with a customer service ticket, move to the sales team for context, and end with the finance department for resolution. When these teams don’t communicate well, the process stalls and customers get frustrated. A successful dispute management system encourages teamwork by creating a single, shared space for communication and action. When everyone has access to the same information, you can resolve issues faster, improve cash flow, and keep your customer relationships strong.
Searching for customer information across different emails, spreadsheets, and platforms is a major time-waster. To truly get a handle on disputes, you need a clear, consistent process and a single source of truth for all your data. Centralizing your information in one system gives your team complete visibility into every dispute. You can see the entire history, track actions in real-time, and ensure everyone follows the same steps. This is where automated systems shine, offering a complete record that makes it easier to collaborate and find the root cause of any issue. Having all your data in one place allows you to make smarter decisions and resolve disputes with confidence.
While having a solid dispute management workflow is crucial for handling issues as they arise, the ultimate goal is to prevent them from happening in the first place. A proactive approach not only saves your team countless hours but also protects your revenue and strengthens customer relationships. Think of it as building a fence at the top of a cliff rather than parking an ambulance at the bottom.
Preventing disputes boils down to clarity, communication, and continuous improvement. It requires creating transparent processes that leave little room for misunderstanding and empowering your team to address potential problems before they escalate. By focusing on a few key practices, you can significantly reduce the frequency and severity of customer disputes. This starts with centralizing your data, communicating openly, training your team, and digging into the "why" behind every issue. These steps help you build a more resilient and customer-focused operation.
When a dispute arises, the last thing you want is your team scrambling through different email chains, spreadsheets, and sticky notes to piece together the story. Using one central place to record all disputes—like a shared portal or a dedicated customer service platform—is a game-changer. This creates a single source of truth, ensuring every team member has access to the same, up-to-date information.
Centralization helps you track the status of each dispute, assign ownership, and ensure nothing falls through the cracks. It eliminates confusion and redundant work, allowing your team to resolve issues faster and more consistently. This principle of a unified data source is why we build our solutions with seamless integrations, connecting disparate systems to give you a clear, complete picture of your financial operations.
Many disputes start as simple misunderstandings that snowball over time. You can prevent this by fostering proactive and transparent communication with your customers from day one. Make sure your contracts, invoices, and service agreements are written in plain language and are easy to understand. Set clear expectations about billing cycles, deliverables, and what to do if a problem occurs.
Make it easy for customers to get in touch with questions or concerns. An accessible support channel or a dedicated account manager can help address small issues before they escalate into formal disputes. When customers feel heard and respected, they are far more likely to work with you toward a solution. This approach builds trust and transforms your customer relationships into true business partnerships.
Dispute management is a team effort. Everyone from sales and IT to accounting and customer service has a role to play. A salesperson who oversells a product or a support agent who doesn't understand the billing process can inadvertently create a dispute. That’s why it’s so important to keep your entire team trained on your products, policies, and dispute resolution procedures.
Regular training sessions empower your employees to handle issues confidently and consistently. When your team understands how to identify potential conflicts, de-escalate tense situations, and follow the proper workflow, they can resolve problems more efficiently. For more ideas on improving your financial processes, you can find helpful articles on our HubiFi blog.
Resolving a dispute is good, but preventing the next one is even better. After a case is closed, always take the time to conduct a root cause analysis to understand why it happened. Was the issue caused by a confusing invoice template, a bug in your software, or a gap in your service delivery? Don't just treat the symptom; find and fix the underlying problem.
By analyzing dispute data over time, you can spot trends and patterns that point to systemic issues. This data-driven approach allows you to make strategic changes that prevent similar disputes from recurring. If you want to see how automated data analysis can provide the visibility needed to uncover these root causes, you can schedule a demo with HubiFi to learn more.
Once you have a dispute management workflow in place, how do you know if it’s actually working? A great process isn’t just about resolving issues as they come up; it’s about continuously improving so fewer disputes happen in the first place. Measuring your success requires looking beyond the number of closed cases. You need to track specific metrics that show you the health of your process, its impact on your finances, and its effect on customer relationships.
By setting clear benchmarks and consistently monitoring your performance, you can turn your dispute management from a reactive necessity into a proactive strategy. This data-driven approach helps you spot weaknesses, celebrate wins, and make informed decisions that protect both your revenue and your reputation. It’s about understanding the story your data is telling you and using those insights to build a more resilient and customer-focused operation. Let’s walk through the key areas you should be measuring.
To get a clear picture of your workflow's effectiveness, you need to track the right Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). Start by monitoring your Dispute Rate, which is the percentage of your total transactions that result in a dispute. A high rate can signal underlying problems with your billing or service delivery. Also, keep a close eye on your Average Resolution Time. This tells you how long it takes your team to resolve a dispute from start to finish and helps you identify any bottlenecks in your process. Finally, tracking the Root Cause Recurrence shows you how often the same problems are causing disputes, pointing you toward the core issues you need to fix for long-term improvement.
Knowing your average resolution time is a great start, but context is everything. How does your performance compare to others in your industry? Benchmarking your resolution times against industry standards gives you a valuable perspective on your efficiency. If you find you’re lagging, it might be time to explore new solutions. For example, businesses that implement AI-powered automation have seen significant improvements in their recovery rates. This technology not only helps streamline the process but also ensures that disputes are handled more quickly and effectively, getting you closer to your financial goals while keeping your team focused on high-value work.
Ultimately, dispute management is about more than just money—it’s about relationships. A clunky, frustrating process can easily drive a customer away for good. That’s why monitoring customer satisfaction throughout the resolution process is so important. Are your customers feeling heard and respected, even when there’s a disagreement? A well-handled dispute can actually strengthen a customer’s loyalty. By ensuring your process is clear, fair, and efficient, you not only protect your cash flow but also show customers you value their business. This focus on the customer experience is key to long-term retention and a healthy bottom line. You can find more insights on financial operations that support a positive customer journey on our blog.
My business is small. Do I really need a formal dispute management process? Absolutely. A formal process doesn't have to be complicated. Even for a small business, having a consistent set of steps ensures that no customer issue gets forgotten in a busy inbox. It helps you resolve problems fairly every time, which builds trust and protects your reputation when you're just starting to grow. Think of it as a simple roadmap that keeps you organized and professional, no matter your size.
What's the difference between dispute management and regular customer service? That's a great question. Think of customer service as the frontline conversation, focused on helping and supporting your clients. Dispute management is the structured, behind-the-scenes process that kicks in when an issue has a direct financial impact, like a billing error or a contract disagreement. It’s about investigating the problem, resolving it systematically, and analyzing the data to prevent it from happening again, all while protecting your cash flow.
You talk a lot about automation. Won't that make the process feel impersonal to my customers? It’s easy to think that, but automation is actually about freeing up your team for more meaningful, human interaction. Instead of spending their time on manual data entry or tracking down invoices, automation handles the repetitive administrative tasks. This gives your team more time and mental space to focus on communicating with the customer, understanding their frustration, and finding the best possible solution.
What's the single most important first step when a customer raises a dispute? The most critical first step is to get the issue out of your email inbox and into a centralized system. Whether you use a simple spreadsheet or a dedicated tool, you need to log the dispute immediately. This creates a single source of truth that you and your team can track. It ensures the problem is officially on your radar and won't get lost in the shuffle, which is the first step toward a fast and fair resolution.
How can I tell if my dispute management process is actually getting better? You can measure your progress by tracking two key things. First, look at your average resolution time—is it getting shorter? This shows your process is becoming more efficient. Second, monitor your overall dispute rate. If you're successfully analyzing the root causes of problems and making changes, you should see the number of new disputes begin to decrease over time. This means you're not just fixing issues, you're preventing them.
Former Root, EVP of Finance/Data at multiple FinTech startups
Jason Kyle Berwanger: An accomplished two-time entrepreneur, polyglot in finance, data & tech with 15 years of expertise. Builder, practitioner, leader—pioneering multiple ERP implementations and data solutions. Catalyst behind a 6% gross margin improvement with a sub-90-day IPO at Root insurance, powered by his vision & platform. Having held virtually every role from accountant to finance systems to finance exec, he brings a rare and noteworthy perspective in rethinking the finance tooling landscape.
Meet with an expert in revenue recognition and order-to-cash accounting and automate revenue close.
*Or watch 2 minute demo here.
Power your high-volume business's revenue compliance and reporting needs with one platform.
